US Edition
Your source for latest news
EntertainmentArt World

Heirs Ask Sotheby's to Pull $180 Million Van Gogh Over Nazi-Era Sale Claim

Descendants of a Jewish publishing family say a 1936 Amsterdam sale of a Van Gogh painting was forced by Nazi persecution, clouding Sotheby's bid to set a record for the artist at Wednesday's New York auction.

PC
By PressTemps Culture DeskPublished Today, 09:03 ET · 4 min read
What to know
Heirs of publisher Samuel Fischer say Van Gogh's "Châtaigniers en Fleurs" was sold under Nazi duress in Amsterdam in 1936 and want it pulled from Sotheby's Nov. 18 sale.
The painting carries a $180 million estimate, which would set a new Van Gogh auction record, breaking the $117.2 million mark set at Christie's in 2022.
Sotheby's says its provenance research has not established the sale was forced, but that it remains in talks with the Fischer family.
The claim rests on the nonbinding 1998 Washington Principles on Nazi-Confiscated Art; the sale predates the German occupation of the Netherlands by four years.

Representatives for the heirs of Samuel Fischer, a German-Jewish publisher, have asked Sotheby's to withdraw Vincent van Gogh's 1890 painting "Châtaigniers en Fleurs" ("Chestnut Trees in Blossom") from its New York sale, arguing the work was sold under duress during Nazi persecution of the family. The painting is the marquee lot of "Legendary: The Blaquier-Arrieta Collection," an evening auction Sotheby's has scheduled for Wednesday at 6 p.m. in New York, carrying a presale estimate of roughly $180 million — a figure that would make it the most expensive Van Gogh ever sold at auction.

Berlin-based lawyer Gunnar Schnabel, who represents the Fischer heirs, sent a letter on Nov. 12 to Marco Toracca, the head of Sotheby's restitution department, arguing that the family sold the painting in Amsterdam in 1936 because Nazi persecution had damaged Fischer's publishing business and forced the family to flee Germany, according to reporting from the Jewish News Syndicate. Sotheby's has said its provenance research "has not established" that the 1936 sale was forced, but that the house remains "in dialogue" with the family, a position confirmed by separate coverage in the Jewish Chronicle.

A Legal Gray Area

The dispute turns on the Washington Conference Principles on Nazi-Confiscated Art, a nonbinding, 11-point framework adopted by 44 governments at a U.S.-hosted international conference in December 1998 that calls for "just and fair" resolutions when art was sold under duress during the Nazi era. The sale at the center of this dispute took place in the Netherlands in 1936 — four years before the German occupation began. The Netherlands has since built its own machinery for weighing such claims; the government-appointed Dutch Restitutions Committee advises on cases involving Dutch-held art, though the Fischer dispute, centered on a private sale to a since-dispersed market rather than a public collection, has not been described in press accounts as pending before that body. Restitution disputes invoking the Washington Principles have multiplied over the past two decades, as heirs and institutions alike have revisited Nazi-era provenance gaps in artworks that changed hands repeatedly, and often quietly, in the years after World War II.

The painting itself has a layered ownership history. According to The Art Newspaper's account of the sale, the work later passed through several private hands before Argentine collectors Carlos Pedro Blaquier and Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier acquired it in 1975; their children are now selling it along with Impressionist and modern works by Monet, Cézanne, Degas and Gauguin as part of a roughly $450 million group of lots. The current Van Gogh auction record, $117.2 million, was set in November 2022 at Christie's for "Verger avec cyprès."

What Happens Next

As of Tuesday, Sotheby's had not announced whether the painting would be withdrawn, postponed or sold as scheduled. The house carries a financial guarantee on the lot, meaning it has committed to a minimum price regardless of the auction's outcome, raising the financial stakes of any last-minute change. The broader "Legendary" sale is set to proceed Wednesday evening alongside Sotheby's separate Modern Evening Auction, with the Fischer family's claim likely to be resolved — or not — in the hours before bidding begins.

More on this story

All Entertainment