Fewer Hospitals Fail Safety Grades, But Court Fight Leaves 450 Unrated
The Leapfrog Group's Fall 2026 Hospital Safety Grades show the largest share of A's on record, but a legal fight over its methodology means hundreds of hospitals carry no public rating at all.

The Leapfrog Group, the Washington-based nonprofit that has graded U.S. hospitals on patient safety since 2012, released its Fall 2026 Hospital Safety Grades on Wednesday, assigning letter grades to 2,367 general hospitals based on their records on infections, surgical complications, falls and medication errors. The twice-a-year report card is one of the few independent, publicly available tools patients can consult before choosing where to have surgery or which emergency room to use in a crisis.
Of the hospitals graded, 900 earned an A, 774 a B, 655 a C, 35 a D and three an F — meaning roughly 38 percent received the top mark, the largest share in the program's history. Connecticut had the highest proportion of A hospitals, at 64 percent, followed by Utah at 55 percent. New Jersey, where 36 hospitals earned an A, ranked third nationally. Five states — Iowa, North Dakota, South Dakota, Vermont and Wyoming — had no A-rated hospital at all. Leapfrog said participation in its voluntary survey, which supplies much of the underlying data alongside federal reporting, reached a record high this cycle.
What actually goes into a grade
The letter grade itself is built from up to 22 measures, split evenly between two categories that each count for half the final score, according to Leapfrog's published scoring methodology. Twelve "process and structural" measures draw mostly on the voluntary Leapfrog Hospital Survey and cover things such as whether a hospital uses computerized physician order entry and bar-code medication administration, how its intensive care units are staffed, adherence to hand-hygiene protocols, and nursing hours per patient day. The remaining measures are outcomes reported to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, anchored by a ten-part federal composite tracking preventable harms such as blood clots, collapsed lungs and objects left behind after surgery, along with rates of hospital-acquired infections. Not every hospital is eligible in the first place: Leapfrog's rules exclude critical-access hospitals, rural emergency hospitals, psychiatric and rehabilitation facilities, federal hospitals such as VA medical centers, and most freestanding specialty and children's hospitals, regardless of the lawsuit described below.
A record release clouded by a legal fight
The numbers released Wednesday came with an asterisk. Roughly 450 hospitals nationwide now carry no grade whatsoever, listed instead as "Grade Not Assigned." The gap traces to a ruling last March, when U.S. District Judge Donald Middlebrooks sided with five Tenet Healthcare-owned hospitals — Good Samaritan Medical Center, St. Mary's Medical Center, Delray Medical Center, Palm Beach Gardens Medical Center and West Boca Medical Center — in a suit brought under Florida's Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act. At issue was a 2024 change to how Leapfrog scored four specific measures — computerized physician order entry, bar-code medication administration, ICU physician staffing and hand-hygiene monitoring — for hospitals that skip its voluntary survey. Before 2024, Leapfrog had filled those gaps with the average score of participating hospitals; afterward, nonparticipating hospitals automatically received the lowest possible score on all four. Middlebrooks found the practice unfair and misleading, writing that it "harm[ed] the hospitals, insurers, employees, and patients" and that "the only beneficiary of this methodology is Leapfrog itself," according to Health News Florida's account of the ruling. He also cited an email in which Binder had called the automatic low score "a major incentive to report to the survey." The injunction ordered Leapfrog to strip the five hospitals' grades for fall 2024, spring 2025 and fall 2025 and to notify anyone who had licensed those grades that they were deceptive. Leapfrog says it is complying while it disagrees; Binder argued at the time that the ruling "threatens the First Amendment rights of every American" and warned it could just as easily be turned against ratings from Amazon, Yelp, Moody's or Experian. Rather than revise the scoring only for the five plaintiff hospitals, Leapfrog chose to stop grading any hospital that has not completed its survey since 2024 — the decision that produced this week's roughly 450 ungraded hospitals — while the case, now captioned Good Samaritan Medical Center Inc. et al. v. The Leapfrog Group, proceeds on appeal before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit.
Price and safety rarely move together
Leapfrog paired the release with a pointed argument about price transparency, drawing on an analysis from the Purchaser Business Group on Health, a coalition of large self-insured employers that has combined federal hospital price-disclosure data with Leapfrog's safety scores. In Seattle, the group found, a hospital with an A grade had negotiated inpatient rates equal to 195 percent to 239 percent of the national Medicare benchmark, while a hospital in the same market carrying a C grade had negotiated rates of 350 percent to 467 percent of that benchmark. Leapfrog says the comparison illustrates that higher negotiated prices do not reliably buy safer care.
"There is no good price for bad care," Leah Binder, Leapfrog's president and chief executive, told Chief Healthcare Executive, adding that "450 communities in the United States have no access to a hospital safety grade."
Who is affected, and what comes next
The practical stakes fall differently on different groups. For consumers, the grade is meant to be a quick, free reference: a hospital's current and historical scores, state rankings and the measures behind them are posted at hospitalsafetygrade.org. Patients in the roughly 450 communities with an ungraded hospital lose that reference for now, a gap Binder has called a public-health problem in its own right — layered atop Leapfrog's existing exclusions for critical-access and federal hospitals. Hospital systems that performed well were quick to publicize it: Keck Hospital of USC and Loma Linda University Medical Center both announced A grades the same day, while hospitals that received a D or F face the opposite — a public mark that can affect reputation and, increasingly, negotiations with insurers and large employers over network inclusion and pricing.
Binder used the release to press a broader policy point. The Trump administration finalized updated Transparency in Coverage rules in October requiring insurers to disclose the prices they negotiate with hospitals and physician groups; Binder said she supports that move but argued Washington should require comparable, standardized safety and quality data published alongside it, so consumers and employers can weigh price against outcomes rather than price alone. Leapfrog's next grades are due in spring 2027. A federal judge already denied Leapfrog's bid to have the March ruling reconsidered back in June, so the fight now rests with the Eleventh Circuit; until it rules, the roughly 450 non-participating hospitals are expected to remain ungraded, leaving a gap in the public record that neither side disputes but that, for now, neither a court order nor a press release has closed.
Herbal Supplement Maker Recalls Yellow Dock Root Over Salmonella Risk

Gelato maker recalls chocolate banana dessert bars after pistachio mix-up

ALDI recalls two Priano tortelloni products in four states over botulism risk
