Health Insurance Premiums Rise Again as Subsidy Cuts Reshape ACA Marketplace
With open enrollment underway and a Dec. 15 deadline approaching, benchmark ACA premiums are climbing for a second straight year as expanded federal subsidies expire and insurers shrink their marketplace footprint.

Open enrollment for Affordable Care Act marketplace coverage is underway, and for the second year in a row, shoppers are confronting steep premium increases just as the federal subsidies that softened earlier cost spikes have disappeared for many of them. The enrollment window, which HealthCare.gov's official dates-and-deadlines page confirms opened Nov. 1 and runs through Jan. 15, carries an earlier, harder deadline for anyone who wants coverage in place on New Year's Day: Dec. 15.
That compressed window matters this year more than most. Benchmark silver-plan premiums — the midtier plans used to calculate federal subsidies — are rising by an average of 13 percent for 2027, according to an analysis from the health policy research organization KFF's rundown of the 2027 open enrollment period. That follows a 26 percent jump the prior year, meaning benchmark premiums have risen roughly 40 percent in just two annual cycles.
The Numbers Behind the Jump
The increase is not uniform. In the roughly three dozen states that rely on the federal HealthCare.gov platform, benchmark premiums are rising about 11 percent; in the states that run their own marketplaces, the increase averages 16 percent. Insurers had initially proposed a median increase of 15 percent before regulators finalized rates. One industry estimate cited by reporting from the National News Desk illustrates the effect on an individual household: a hypothetical 40-year-old in Arizona earning $65,000 a year could see a Blue Cross Blue Shield marketplace premium climb from roughly $300 a month in 2025 to about $555 a month in 2027, a nearly 85 percent increase over two years, according to an analysis the outlet attributed to The Washington Post.
Federal officials, for their part, emphasize a different set of figures. A fact sheet published by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services on Oct. 30 says more than 75 percent of HealthCare.gov shoppers will still be able to find a plan priced at $50 a month or less, and that enrollees qualifying for tax credits can get the government to cover close to 90 percent of the lowest-cost plan's premium. CMS also touts a roughly tenfold increase in the number of health-savings-account-eligible plans on offer. Those figures describe the subsidized floor of the market; they do not describe what happens to the roughly one in five enrollees who no longer qualify for any subsidy at all.
Why Premiums Keep Climbing
The proximate cause is the lapse of the enhanced premium tax credits that Congress first approved during the pandemic and extended through 2025. Those credits eliminated the income cap on subsidy eligibility and reduced what middle-income households owed out of pocket. With that enhancement gone, anyone earning more than 400 percent of the federal poverty level — about $62,600 for a single person — now pays the full, unsubsidized premium.
Insurers say the effect compounds itself. As healthier or more price-sensitive customers drop coverage rather than pay full freight, the remaining pool of enrollees skews toward people with higher expected medical costs, which pushes premiums up further for everyone who stays. KFF's analysts estimate that this "risk pool" shift alone added roughly four percentage points to premiums last year and expect a similar effect this year, on top of ordinary medical inflation.
Insurers Are Retreating From the Market
Pricing isn't the only sign of strain. As of late October, 11 insurers had told regulators they are leaving at least one state's individual marketplace for 2027, while only seven announced plans to enter new states, according to KFF's insurer-tracking data. The most consequential exit is Cigna's, which is withdrawing from the individual exchange business entirely in all 11 states where it sold ACA plans, affecting roughly 369,000 members. It follows Aetna's departure from the marketplace at the end of 2025, which displaced about 1 million enrollees across 17 states. Members in affected states aren't losing coverage outright, but they must actively shop for a new plan during this enrollment period rather than letting their old plan auto-renew.
The combined effect on enrollment is already visible in federal data. Plan selections during the 2026 sign-up period fell by 1.2 million from the year before, and by this past February, the number of people actually paying premiums and remaining covered — "effectuated" enrollment, in the government's terminology — had dropped 12 percent, or 2.6 million people, to 19.2 million.
A Separate Fight Over Who Is Actually Enrolled
Layered on top of the subsidy and pricing changes is an enforcement campaign that has removed hundreds of thousands of people from the rolls. In September, CMS announced it had canceled about 315,000 enrollments covering more than 760,000 people that it determined were unauthorized, a move it says will return roughly $2.2 billion in subsidies to the Treasury. The agency simultaneously imposed a temporary moratorium, running into February, on new agent and broker registrations for the federal marketplace, after finding that newly registered brokers accounted for a disproportionate share of the flagged enrollments.
"We are using our data, enforcement authorities, and stronger safeguards to identify fraud and abuse, stop it, and recover taxpayer dollars. We are making sure Americans — not bad actors — remain in control of their health coverage," CMS Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz said in the agency's Sept. 22 announcement.
Consumer advocates and some health policy researchers have questioned how the agency verified that the canceled enrollments were improper, and some people removed from the rolls have since had coverage reinstated after disputing the finding. Separately, eligibility for premium tax credits has also narrowed for certain immigrants: starting with this enrollment period, only lawful permanent residents, Cuban and Haitian entrants, and a small number of other categories can receive subsidies, while other lawfully present immigrants, including refugees and asylees, can still buy marketplace plans but without financial help.
Who Is Affected, and What Comes Next
The households most exposed are solidly middle-income: self-employed workers, early retirees, and small-business owners who buy coverage on their own and earn just above the subsidy cutoff. Lower-income enrollees are more insulated, since most still qualify for some assistance, though KFF notes that many have already shifted into bare-bones bronze plans to hold down premiums. A new wrinkle arrives in 2027 as well — most states must implement Medicaid work requirements by Jan. 1, and adults who lose Medicaid solely for failing to meet those requirements will also be barred from marketplace tax credits, closing off what had been a fallback option.
Not every state is leaving enrollees to absorb the full increase. At least a handful of states, including Virginia, Rhode Island, New Mexico and California, have created or expanded their own premium-assistance programs for 2027 to offset some of the lost federal support, though eligibility and funding vary widely by state and none replaces the federal subsidy in full.
For now, the practical advice from enrollment counselors is unchanged: current enrollees should not assume their existing plan will auto-renew at a comparable price, since insurer exits and repriced plans mean last year's "benchmark" plan may no longer be the cheapest option. Shoppers who want coverage starting Jan. 1 need to select a plan by Dec. 15; those who miss that date still have until Jan. 15 to enroll, but coverage would not begin until February at the earliest.
National Adoption Day draws hundreds of ceremonies as foster-care adoptions hit a record low
Thanksgiving Dinner Costs Rise for the First Time Since 2022, Farm Bureau Survey Finds

Flu activity surges nationwide, pushing hospitalizations to their highest mid-November level since 2010
