Opinion: Washington's Obamacare Fraud Crackdown Is Punishing the Wrong People
A federal crackdown on fraudulent Affordable Care Act enrollments is real and overdue, but the government's own evidence shows it is being run with weak safeguards — at the exact moment subsidy cuts and premium spikes are already pushing people out of the marketplace.

Open enrollment for 2027 Affordable Care Act marketplace plans began November 1 and runs through January 15, and it is unfolding under a cloud that has little to do with premiums. Since late September, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services has been canceling what it calls "unauthorized" coverage on a mass scale: roughly 315,000 enrollments covering more than 760,000 people, according to a CMS press release announcing the action, with the agency projecting it will claw back about $2.2 billion in subsidies paid to insurers on those consumers' behalf. A companion freeze now bars most new insurance agents and brokers from registering on the federal marketplace through the 2027 plan year.
Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. framed the action as a straightforward matter of stopping theft of taxpayer money, and CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz put the stakes in more personal terms.
"We are making sure Americans — not bad actors — remain in control of their health coverage."
That would be a reassuring sentence if the government's own evidence supported it. It does not, fully. A nonpartisan Government Accountability Office report issued in July confirms the underlying problem is genuine: confirmed consumer complaints about unauthorized enrollments and plan switches on the federal exchange more than quadrupled from 2023 through 2025. But the same report found that CMS's safeguards against exactly this kind of fraud are themselves inadequate — agents can run a person-search using nothing more than a name and birthdate, consent is not meaningfully verified, and consumers are not notified when their records are searched or changed. GAO's conclusion was not that fraud is being chased with precision. It was that CMS built a system porous enough for both bad actors and sloppy error to produce the same result, and then, this fall, used a process it has not fully disclosed to decide which of the two had occurred in any given case.
A crackdown with an undisclosed rulebook
CMS has said coverage was canceled for enrollees who did not respond to insurer outreach confirming their selection — a reasonable-sounding standard until one asks who actually receives and understands that outreach. Marketplace enrollees skew toward people with unstable addresses, irregular broker relationships, and limited English proficiency: the self-employed, gig workers, early retirees bridging the gap to Medicare, and low-income workers in states that never expanded Medicaid. The agency's own fact sheet on the anti-fraud actions does not publish a breakdown of how many of the 760,000 canceled enrollees it has independently confirmed never consented to coverage, versus how many simply failed to answer a letter or a call. Some cancellations have already been reversed after consumers complained they had done nothing wrong. A government that wants credit for stopping fraud owes the public that accounting before, not after, it cancels health coverage for three-quarters of a million people.
The numbers behind the sales pitch
The crackdown is landing in a season when the marketplace is already contracting on its own. The enhanced premium tax credits that made coverage affordable for middle-income buyers expired at the end of 2025, and insurers say that alone added several points to this year's rate increases as healthier enrollees left the risk pool. Independent analysts at KFF calculate that finalized 2027 benchmark silver premiums are rising 13% on average nationally — the second straight year of double-digit increases, following a 26% jump the year before — and that enrollment has already fallen by more than a fifth since last year. Eleven insurers, including Cigna in every state where it sold marketplace plans, are exiting markets for 2027.
CMS's own promotional fact sheet for 2027 plans emphasizes that more than three-quarters of HealthCare.gov shoppers can find a plan priced at $50 a month or less. That is true and also beside the point: it describes what heavily subsidized buyers can pay after assistance, not the benchmark rates insurers actually charge, which is the number driving the sticker shock and the exodus of unsubsidized, moderate-income buyers who lost their credits entirely once their income crossed 400% of the federal poverty line. Separate budget analysis prepared for Senate Democrats has projected several million more uninsured people over the coming decade specifically because of the credits' expiration — a channel of coverage loss distinct from anything attributable to fraud.
Who actually bears the cost
Put the two trends together and the people losing coverage this winter are not, in the main, fraud rings. They are low- and middle-income households already being squeezed out by price, now facing an additional administrative gauntlet to prove they belong in the system at all. States have responded unevenly: New Mexico and California have expanded their own subsidy backfills, and New Jersey, Rhode Island and Virginia created new state-funded assistance for 2027, but most states offer nothing comparable, meaning a consumer's odds of staying insured now depend heavily on which state they live in rather than on need. Layered on top, Medicaid work requirements take effect in 43 states and the District of Columbia on January 1, 2027, and anyone dropped from Medicaid for failing to document compliance will also be ineligible for marketplace subsidies — closing off the usual backstop.
The fraud was real; the remedy is overbroad
None of this means the crackdown is cynical invention. "Ghost" policies — coverage switched or created without a consumer's knowledge, often to generate a broker commission — were a documented scandal, and GAO's complaint data back up the administration's claim that the problem grew sharply under lax federal oversight. A temporary broker moratorium and stronger identity-proofing are defensible responses, and some of the premium growth genuinely reflects rising medical costs rather than policy choices, a point insurers make in their own rate filings. The honest critique is not that Washington should ignore fraud. It is that a government agency canceling coverage for three-quarters of a million people, by a method it has not fully explained, in the same season it is also letting hundreds of billions of dollars in subsidies lapse, has an obligation to show its work with far more rigor than a press release and a round number.
Open enrollment runs another two months. The broker freeze lifts in February. GAO's recommendations for better verification remain, by the agency's own admission, unimplemented as of this spring. Until that changes, the safest assumption is that the marketplace now loses customers on two fronts at once — to price and to an enforcement regime that has not yet proven it can tell the difference between a fraud and a form letter that never got answered.
Opinion: Washington wants its own rules for killer robots, not the world's

Opinion: Amazon's new Bond is a bet against the safe choice

Opinion: Europe Wrote a Migration Pact for Moments Like This. Spain Won't Use It.
