US Edition
Your source for latest news
PoliticsNorth Carolina

Democrat edges out House Rules Committee chair in tight North Carolina recount race

Rep. Virginia Foxx, an 11-term Republican who chairs the powerful House Rules Committee, trails Democrat Chuck Hubbard by roughly 325 votes after North Carolina counted provisional ballots, with Tuesday's noon deadline to request a recount arriving as the state moves toward certification.

PW
By PressTemps Washington DeskPublished Today, 20:05 ET · 5 min
Democrat edges out House Rules Committee chair in tight North Carolina recount race
Official photo of Rep. Virginia Foxx (R-N.C.). Credit: U.S. House Office of Photography, via Wikimedia Commons (public domain).
What to know
Democrat Chuck Hubbard leads 11-term Republican Rep. Virginia Foxx by about 325 votes in North Carolina's 5th District after provisional and cured ballots were counted.
Foxx chairs the House Rules Committee, one of the chamber's most powerful posts; the deadline to request a recount was noon Tuesday, Nov. 17, with state certification set for Nov. 24.
North Carolina law allows a recount request when the margin is 1% or less of votes cast; roughly 280,000 ballots were cast in this race, putting the gap well inside that threshold.
A Hubbard win would be Democrats' 11th North Carolina House seat flip this cycle, reversing the GOP's prior 10-of-14 hold on the state's congressional delegation.

More than two decades after she first won North Carolina's 5th Congressional District, Republican Rep. Virginia Foxx is on the verge of losing her seat, and with it, the gavel of the House Rules Committee, one of the most powerful positions in Congress. As of Monday, Democratic challenger Chuck Hubbard led Foxx by several hundred votes after county election boards finished counting provisional and cured ballots, and Tuesday brought the noon deadline for Foxx to request a recount before the state moves toward certifying the result.

The race has tightened and flipped repeatedly since polls closed on Nov. 3. Hubbard, a retired Wilkes County newspaper editor making his first run for office, started election night with a 99-vote edge. Foxx briefly pulled ahead the following Tuesday, only for Hubbard to regain the lead after Guilford and Watauga counties reported a net gain of 385 votes for him, according to WUNC. With provisional and cured ballots now counted, Hubbard's lead stands at 325 votes out of roughly 280,000 cast.

A margin inside the recount threshold

Under North Carolina law, a candidate in a non-statewide race may request a recount when the margin separating the two leading candidates is 1 percent or less of the total votes cast, a threshold spelled out in the state's election recount statute. A roughly 325-vote gap out of 280,000 ballots falls comfortably within that window. The State Board of Elections' own explanation of the recount process notes that any recount is conducted by county boards, is open to the public, and requires at least 48 hours' notice before it begins. Requests for the 5th District seat had to reach the state board by noon Tuesday, the same day county boards were finishing their canvasses; the State Board of Elections is scheduled to certify the result, along with other multi-county contests, on Nov. 24.

The outcome carries unusual weight because of who is losing. Foxx, first elected in 2004, is seeking an 11th term and currently chairs the House Rules Committee, the panel that controls which bills reach the House floor and under what conditions. She previously led the House Education and the Workforce Committee, which she still serves as chair emerita, according to her official biography on her House website. The Rules Committee's own description of its mandate underscores how central the post is to the chamber's daily operations.

A district redrawn, and a race decades in the making

North Carolina's 5th District stretches across the state's northwestern corner, taking in Boone, Wilkes, Alleghany and Ashe counties along with a slice of Guilford County near Greensboro. Foxx has represented some version of the district for more than 20 years and has rarely faced a serious general-election challenge. This cycle was different: Democrats targeted the seat as part of a broader push that, according to WUNC's count, could flip an 11th North Carolina congressional district to Democratic control, reversing a map that had Republicans holding 10 of the state's 14 seats heading into Election Day.

Hubbard, who spent decades as a reporter and associate publisher at a Wilkes County newspaper, entered the race motivated in part by his daughter, who is gay and who he has said raised concerns about discrimination and the future of same-sex marriage protections. He has made that personal history part of his campaign, telling local reporters:

"I will do whatever, whenever, however I can to protect the LGBTQ community."

That framing has drawn a direct contrast with Foxx's record. During her time in Congress, she has opposed the Supreme Court's 2015 ruling legalizing same-sex marriage and, in a 2010 floor speech, described the 1998 killing of Matthew Shepard, a gay college student whose murder helped spur federal hate-crimes legislation, as a "hoax," according to WUNC's reporting on her legislative history. Those positions have become a recurring theme in Hubbard's campaign messaging, laid out on his campaign website, which also emphasizes protecting Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security and preserving abortion access.

Both sides brace for the next two weeks

Neither campaign has declared victory outright. When he first pulled ahead on election night, Hubbard described his reaction as "jubilation, absolute jubilation," while cautioning that "we expect to win this race" only once the count was final. Foxx has maintained publicly that the count is not over, a position she reiterated as the margin narrowed in the days after the election. National Democrats have cast the extended count as a matter of process rather than politics. Madison Andrus, a spokesperson for the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, said in a statement reported by WUNC: "From the beginning we have been committed to ensuring that every legal vote in North Carolina is counted."

The district's outcome will not change which party controls the House, since Democrats already secured a majority in the broader midterm results. But it would end the congressional career of one of the chamber's more institutionally powerful Republicans at a moment when the party is already absorbing a difficult election. Hubbard has already traveled to Washington for new-member orientation even as the race remained uncalled, a sign of how confident Democrats have grown about the trend lines, according to WBTV's coverage of the race.

What happens next depends largely on whether Foxx's campaign files a recount request before Tuesday's deadline. If she does not, or if a recount does not change the outcome, the State Board of Elections' Nov. 24 certification would make Hubbard's win official and end Foxx's run in the House after more than two decades, reshaping the leadership of the Rules Committee heading into a new Congress where Republicans will also have lost their House majority.

More on this story

All Politics