Court halts Army's plan to blow up unstable explosive at Iowa plant
A federal appeals court froze an EPA permit hours before the Army planned to detonate nearly five tons of degraded lead azide in Middletown, Iowa, after environmental groups warned the blast could spread lead-laced dust across the Mississippi River valley.

A federal appeals court has halted, at least for now, the Army's plan to blow up nearly five tons of degraded military explosive at a plant in southeastern Iowa, after environmental groups warned that the blast could send lead-contaminated dust across a wide swath of the Mississippi River valley.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit granted an emergency administrative stay late Thursday, freezing an Environmental Protection Agency permit that would have allowed the Army to detonate 68 drums of lead azide at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in Middletown, a town of roughly 360 people west of Burlington. The stay has no expiration date and will remain in place until the court rules on a longer-term motion filed by the Iowa Environmental Council and the Sierra Club's Iowa chapter.
What the Army wanted to do
The lead azide at issue, about 9,500 pounds of it, had been stored for more than two decades in earth-covered magazines at the plant, submerged in an ethanol-and-water bath meant to keep the compound stable. A routine inspection this year found that much of that liquid had evaporated, leaving behind recrystallized material that the EPA says has become far more sensitive to friction and shock than when it was first placed in storage, a risk the agency had already flagged in a previous extension of the plant's storage permit.
Lead azide has been used as a detonator compound in munitions since World War I because small amounts of shock or heat can set it off. The EPA, in a series of emergency permits issued this year under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, concluded that the degraded material posed "an imminent and substantial endangerment" to people and the environment if it were disturbed during ordinary handling, and authorized the Army to store it in place while it worked out a disposal method. The Army ultimately settled on a controlled, open-air detonation at the site as what Acting Army Secretary Adam Telle has called the safest way to destroy the material without moving or repackaging the aging drums.
Two blasts had been scheduled for around noon Friday. Under the Army's public advisory, residents in the Middletown City Park neighborhood closest to the detonation site were told to leave their homes between 8 a.m. and 2 p.m., partly out of concern that the shock wave could break windows. The Army said the explosions would also throw up a dust plume containing lead particles that could linger for up to an hour depending on wind conditions, and it set up a shelter with refreshments at a nearby Armed Forces Reserve Center for evacuated families and their pets.
A contested blast radius
The Army's own modeling, cited in this week's court filings, projected that fallout from the detonation could settle over a corridor roughly 25 miles long and five miles wide, covering farmland, waterways and homes in both Iowa and Illinois. The Iowa Environmental Council and Sierra Club, represented by the nonprofit law firm Earthjustice, argued in their Eighth Circuit filing that lead dust could in some weather conditions travel 100 miles or more, and that the EPA had rushed the permitting process, giving residents too little notice, withholding the technical basis for its decision from public review, and failing to seriously evaluate alternatives such as chemical neutralization of the compound.
The groups also argued that the government had not adequately studied long-term contamination risks to soil, groundwater and the Mississippi River, which lies within the projected plume path and near the plant's roughly 19,000-acre footprint. The Justice Department has signaled it will oppose the stay motion, telling the court it plans to file its response by Sunday. In its own filings, the department reiterated the EPA's finding that the deteriorating explosive presents a genuine, near-term danger on its own, separate from any risk posed by the cleanup method chosen to address it.
Facing the legal and political pressure, Telle had already pushed the detonation back once, from Friday to Monday, saying that was the latest the material could safely wait given a forecast cold front that officials feared could make the lead azide even less stable. The Eighth Circuit's stay, issued hours after that announcement, now leaves the Monday date in doubt as well, with no new schedule set.
Who is affected
Middletown itself sits almost entirely within a few miles of the plant, and residents in the City Park neighborhood have spent the past week preparing to leave their homes on short notice. Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds activated the State Emergency Operations Center on Friday evening at the request of the Iowa Emergency Management Association, which also asked for a disaster emergency proclamation covering potentially affected counties. The governor's office said it was "actively coordinating" with the EPA and the Army on the response.
Concern has not stayed within Iowa's borders. Because the Army's plume projections cross the Mississippi River into northwestern Illinois, a bipartisan group of elected officials from both states signed a letter this week urging the Pentagon and the EPA to delay the operation while safer alternatives were studied. Signers included Illinois Sens. Dick Durbin and Tammy Duckworth, Reps. Darin LaHood, Mary Miller and Eric Sorensen, Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker, and Iowa Sens.-elect Juliana Stratton and Josh Turek.
"Iowa and Illinois residents understandably are concerned about the potential health impacts of the scheduled detonation."
Public health officials have focused on lead's well-documented risks to children and pregnant women even at low exposure levels, and on the difficulty of fully decontaminating farmland, lawns and playgrounds once lead dust settles into soil. The Army's permit requires pre- and post-detonation soil and air sampling, perimeter air monitoring during the blast, and wetting of the ground near the detonation site to limit dust, but the environmental groups argue those measures do not address exposure beyond the immediate evacuation zone.
What happens next
For now, the detonation cannot proceed while the Eighth Circuit considers the emergency stay motion. Earthjustice attorneys have said a ruling could come before Monday but have not predicted a timeline. The Justice Department's response opposing the stay is due Sunday, which it has said will argue the injunction should be lifted, after which the three-judge panel could rule at any time.
The underlying EPA emergency permit allowing lead azide to remain stored at the site, as opposed to the separate authorization for detonating it, is set to expire December 26 unless extended again, the third such extension since the deterioration was first detected this spring. Army officials have said they still intend to destroy the material by controlled detonation if the courts ultimately allow it, and have not publicly outlined a backup disposal method should the permit be vacated. Until the litigation is resolved, the lead azide remains in its earth-covered magazines in Middletown, and families in the City Park neighborhood remain on notice that they could be asked to evacuate again with little warning.



