New York City Unveils Detailed Plan to Close Rikers Island Jail
City officials released a road map Friday for shutting down the troubled jail complex on Rikers Island and moving detainees into four borough-based facilities, though construction delays mean the plan will miss its original 2027 legal deadline.

New York City officials on Friday released the administration's most detailed plan yet for shutting down the Rikers Island jail complex, laying out a timeline for moving thousands of detainees into four smaller, borough-based jails after decades of reports of violence, neglect and in-custody deaths at the facility.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani's administration said the plan addresses both the physical conditions inside the jail system and the size of the population held behind bars, which city officials say must shrink substantially before the new facilities can open. "It is long past time to close what's been a moral stain on our city," Mamdani said, adding that the city "cannot simply accept the old approaches to public safety just because they've always been done that way."
A jail already under federal control
Rikers sits on a former garbage dump in the East River between Queens and the Bronx, and it has drawn complaints of crumbling infrastructure, excessive force and sexual assault for decades. More than 50 people have died in the custody of the city's Department of Correction since 2022, nearly all of them while held at Rikers; some died by suicide, others were beaten to death or found unresponsive in their cells.
A class-action lawsuit brought by the Legal Aid Society led a federal judge to strip the city of direct authority over the jail last year after finding the level of violence there posed an "unconstitutional danger" to detainees and staff alike. A court-appointed remediation manager, Nicholas Deml, now oversees day-to-day operations under a separate compliance plan filed with the federal court that sets monthly benchmarks for basic security practices, independent of the mayor's closure plan released this week. That takeover marked the first time a judge had stripped the city of control over its own jail system.
- More than 6,600 people are currently held at Rikers, the vast majority of them awaiting trial rather than serving sentences.
- The four new borough jails, still years from completion, are expected to hold roughly 2,000 fewer people combined than Rikers does now.
- Nearly a quarter of people held at Rikers have been there more than a year, and the average length of stay in city custody was almost double in 2025 what it was a decade earlier, according to the policy journal Vital City.
- The city's plan commits more than $250 million over several years to alternatives to incarceration, including diversion programs and electronic monitoring.
A 2019 deadline the city already concedes it will miss
The City Council approved the original plan to close Rikers by August 2027 and replace it with jails in Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens and the Bronx back in 2019. Progress has been slow: the city missed its own legal deadline earlier this year to release a detailed closure report, and officials now acknowledge construction on the borough jails will not be finished for roughly six more years. Mamdani has named Dana Kaplan as a "Close Rikers Czar" and appointed Stanley Richards, the first formerly incarcerated person to lead the Department of Correction, as commissioner. In June, the city permanently shut one Rikers building, the North Infirmary Command, and transferred three other facilities out of correctional use, a step the administration called a milestone.
Part of the new plan's thinking draws on a trip Deml and Richards took to Germany this year, organized by the Vera Institute of Justice, where they toured prisons regarded internationally as humane models. A second delegation of New Yorkers, including a prosecutor, a judge and a city council member, visited Berlin's Moabit jail last month and found cells with windows, doors connecting adjoining cells, televisions and even a vending machine selling cigarettes in the hallway. Christopher Watler, who recently became chair of the New York City Board of Correction, said the trip underscored how far the city's own jails have to go.
"New York City's a great city. Our jail system isn't great," Watler said. "It's a broken thing. But how do you repair broken things?"
Reaction divided over whether the numbers will add up
Insha Rahman, president of the Vera Institute, called the plan an ambitious model for other large cities. "If New York City can do this at scale, which it will, it is encouragement for places like LA, like Chicago, like Philadelphia, like Houston to do the same," she said. Vera has noted the city's latest budget adds $43 million a year in new funding for jail programming starting next year.
Others who have worked on the issue are more cautious. Vincent Schiraldi, who served as correction commissioner under former Mayor Bill de Blasio and now runs a philanthropic fund dedicated to closing Rikers, said forecasting a shrinking jail population is politically risky. "It's really hard to have the guts to forecast lower incarceration numbers," he said. "Because if you are wrong, then you have crowded jails and you're in trouble." He pointed to New Orleans, which cut its jail population by more than two-thirds in the decade after Hurricane Katrina, as evidence that large reductions are achievable.
Elizabeth Glazer, who led the city's Office of Criminal Justice under de Blasio and now runs the policy outlet Vital City, said she hopes officials have a contingency plan, including the possibility of building again on Rikers Island, if the population does not fall enough. "It requires relentless attention, coordination and organization around a common goal to get it done," she said. Tina Luongo, who leads the criminal defense practice at the Legal Aid Society, the organization whose lawsuit triggered the federal takeover, said inaction has its own costs. "We wait for these perfect plans, and for all the reasons we know, including funding, those perfect plans never come to pass," she said. "And so what do we do? We do nothing."
What happens next
Construction continues on the Brooklyn facility, expected to open first, while the Bronx and Queens jails and a Manhattan site are projected to follow over the next several years. City officials say they are also forming a task force to speed up how quickly criminal cases move through court, since lengthy pretrial delays are a major driver of the jail population; that effort depends on cooperation from judges and district attorneys, who operate independently of City Hall. Chief Administrative Judge Joseph Zayas of the New York State Unified Court System said no single fix will resolve the backlog. "The only way to solve this backlog problem is to hit each of these things," he said. "The sum of all of the efforts will help."
Commissioner Richards, who was himself incarcerated at Rikers roughly 40 years ago, said changing the jail's culture — including how officers treat both detainees and each other — will take longer than any single construction timeline. "Everybody wants something to happen by tomorrow. And we are in a moment of urgency," he said. "But it takes time to turn."
NPR — New York City unveils a bold plan to move its jails off Rikers Island
CBS News New York — NYC loses control of Rikers Island as judge appoints remediation manager
Queens Eagle — City misses deadline to release Rikers shutdown plan
Vera Institute of Justice — Yes, We Can Close Rikers Island for Good



