US Edition
Your source for latest news
World NewsUnited Nations

UN States Agree to Draft Rules on 'Killer Robots,' Leaving Binding Question Unresolved

Delegates from 128 countries agreed early Saturday to spend two years drafting international rules on autonomous weapons systems, but left open whether the result will carry the force of law.

PW
By PressTemps World DeskPublished Yesterday, 04:58 ET · 5 min
UN States Agree to Draft Rules on 'Killer Robots,' Leaving Binding Question Unresolved
The "Broken Chair" sculpture, a longstanding disarmament symbol, stands outside the Palais des Nations in Geneva, where the UN's autonomous-weapons talks concluded Saturday. Photo: That1RandomHuman / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0
What to know
128 countries at the UN's Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons agreed in Geneva early Saturday to spend two years drafting international rules on autonomous weapons, with a rough 2028 target
The agreement does not resolve whether the eventual rules will be legally binding; a drafting group must still recommend the instrument's legal form
More than 95 states backed binding rules, according to the Stop Killer Robots coalition, but the United States and Russia favored non-binding national guidelines instead
The deal follows a September breakthrough in which the same 128 states agreed for the first time on a formal definition of a lethal autonomous weapons system

Diplomats from 128 countries ended five days of talks in Geneva early Saturday by agreeing to spend the next two years drafting international rules on autonomous weapons systems, often called "killer robots," while leaving unresolved the central question of whether those rules will ever be legally binding.

The Seventh Review Conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, held at the Palais des Nations under Swiss Ambassador Julien Thöni, ran past 4:45 a.m. local time before reaching consensus, the threshold required for any decision under the 1980 convention. Thöni told delegates they had "agreed to launch the elaboration of an international instrument on lethal autonomous weapons systems," according to the Geneva-based wire report carried by Asharq Al-Awsat. The text does not specify whether that instrument will take the form of a treaty with legal force or a voluntary set of guidelines; a drafting group is now expected to make a recommendation on that question over the coming two years, putting a rough deadline of 2028 on the process.

A fight over one word: binding

The outcome reflects a split that has defined the talks for years. Most of the 128 states that are party to the convention want a treaty with real legal force. Stop Killer Robots, a coalition the group describes as representing more than 300 nongovernmental organizations, said more than 95 states had backed a binding instrument, but that a small number of governments with advanced weapons programs weakened the final mandate. The campaign called the result watered down. The United States and Russia, both developers of autonomous weapons systems, pushed instead for a slower, non-binding approach built around national guidelines rather than an enforceable international instrument.

Human Rights Watch's Verity Coyle said the underlying technology is "racing ahead" of the diplomacy meant to govern it, a line that captured the frustration of advocacy groups that had hoped the conference, held only once every five years, would produce something closer to a negotiating mandate for an actual treaty. Rain Liivoja, of the Asia-Pacific Institute for Law and Security, was blunter about the odds, saying it remains likely there will be no treaty in place by the end of 2028 even under the new timetable.

Izumi Nakamitsu, the United Nations Under-Secretary-General for Disarmament Affairs, described the two-year window as "very compressed" but said a legally binding instrument "remains possible." She has overseen the process since the UN's Group of Governmental Experts on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems began its work a decade ago.

What was actually agreed in September

Saturday's outcome builds on a narrower breakthrough reached in Geneva two months earlier. In the early hours of September 5, the same expert group, after three years of negotiation, agreed by consensus for the first time on a formal description of what counts as a lethal autonomous weapons system — a device able to select and engage targets without further human intervention once activated. That text, non-binding on its own, set out "elements" that could eventually form the basis of a protocol, including a requirement that human judgment remain part of a weapon's life cycle, from design through deployment.

Governments were divided then, too. The European Union's delegation, in a statement to the convention's preparatory committee, had pressed for the review conference to adopt an ambitious mandate carrying the expert group's work into formal treaty negotiations. France's foreign ministry, in its own account of the expert group's sessions, noted that the September report left the question of the instrument's legal nature deliberately open, a choice that foreshadowed Saturday's compromise.

Why Geneva, and why now

The push for rules has gathered urgency as autonomous and semi-autonomous weapons move from research programs into active use. A 2021 United Nations Panel of Experts report on Libya's civil war described what is widely cited as the first documented battlefield use of a weapons system operating in autonomous mode against human targets. Since then, drone warfare in Ukraine and elsewhere has accelerated the integration of machine-assisted targeting into frontline combat, lending weight to warnings from humanitarian lawyers that the technology is outpacing the rules meant to constrain it.

Opening the conference on November 16, UN Secretary-General António Guterres told delegates the "nature of warfare is changing" and urged them to move toward a legally binding instrument with "clear prohibitions and restrictions" on weapons he called "merciless," according to a UN News account of his remarks to representatives of more than 120 member states. Days earlier, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk had made a similar appeal, arguing that "a machine must never have the power to decide whether a human being survives or dies," a position humanitarian groups including the International Committee of the Red Cross have echoed throughout the talks.

"The two-year timeframe is very compressed, but a legally binding instrument remains possible."

That line, from Nakamitsu, is as close as any official came Saturday to summarizing where the process now stands: a mandate to keep working, with no guarantee of where the work will end.

Who is affected, and what comes next

The immediate stakes fall on militaries already fielding or developing autonomous targeting systems, the defense and technology firms supplying them, and — in the view of advocacy groups — civilians in active conflict zones who could be exposed to weapons making life-and-death decisions without a human directly in the loop. The convention's consensus rule means any one of its 128 parties can still block a binding outcome when the drafting group reports back, a dynamic that has repeatedly slowed this process since the expert group was first established in 2016.

There is a parallel track that could matter more than Geneva eventually does. A UN General Assembly resolution adopted on December 1, 2025, urged states to complete work on the elements for an instrument and placed lethal autonomous weapons on the agenda of the Assembly's 81st session. Because the General Assembly operates by majority vote rather than consensus, supporters of a binding ban have signaled they could use that forum to apply pressure that a single objecting state cannot block in Geneva. For now, though, the formal process remains inside the convention, with a drafting group due to report on both the substance of the rules and their legal character before the informal 2028 target date arrives.

More on this story

All World News