US Edition
Your source for latest news
OpinionHealth Policy

Opinion: Nebraska rushed Medicaid work rules, and a cancer patient paid the price

Nebraska volunteered to be the first state to enforce Medicaid work requirements, and its first six months show the damage is falling on exemption-eligible patients tangled in paperwork, not the "able-bodied" shirkers the policy claims to target. More than 40 states face the same deadline in 2027, and they should read Nebraska's numbers as a warning, not a model.

PW
By PressTemps Washington DeskPublished November 20, 2026 · 7 min read
Opinion: Nebraska rushed Medicaid work rules, and a cancer patient paid the price
The Nebraska State Capitol in Lincoln, photographed in July 2026. Nebraska's state government became the first in the nation to enforce Medicaid work requirements, launching the program on May 1, 2026. (Photo: Hurstbergn via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0)
What to know
Nebraska became the first state to enforce Medicaid work requirements on May 1, 2026, applying an 80-hour-a-month rule to roughly 70,000 expansion enrollees, months ahead of the national January 1, 2027 deadline set by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act.
State data shows about 1,100 people were denied Medicaid benefits by early July under the new rules, mostly for unsubmitted paperwork rather than actual ineligibility; Human Rights Watch separately counted more than 1,000 people losing or being denied coverage between May and August.
Nebraska budgeted $8.2 million over two years for outside contractors to run the verification system, with at least six contracts exceeding $250,000 and one consultant paid more than $1.8 million, even as call-center wait times nearly doubled.
More than 40 additional states must stand up similar Medicaid work-reporting systems by January 1, 2027, making Nebraska's rollout the only real-world test case available before the mandate goes nationwide.

In June, Eli McCreary, a 64-year-old Omaha man managing diabetes, COPD and a decades-long struggle with addiction, was diagnosed with kidney cancer. Soon after, he says, a hospital billing office told him his Medicaid coverage had lapsed and his scans would not be covered unless he paid out of pocket. A call-center representative, he recalled, put it bluntly: he was "required to do work to stay on." He canceled a CT scan and delayed a follow-up appointment before the confusion was sorted out and he had his right kidney removed in early November, according to KFF Health News' investigation into the rollout. Nebraska's health department disputes the specifics of his case, saying he was moved to Medicare after turning 65 rather than cut off for failing to document work hours. What is not in dispute is the program that put him in that position in the first place, or the fact that it is about to be replicated in every state in the country.

Nebraska became the first state in the nation to enforce Medicaid work requirements, switching the mandate on for roughly 70,000 expansion enrollees on May 1, 2026, months ahead of the national deadline. Governor Jim Pillen and Trump administration health official Mehmet Oz made the early rollout a point of pride, with Pillen declaring at the launch, "We're excited to be able to be the first to make it happen," according to the governor's own announcement. The requirement itself traces to the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, the budget reconciliation law that added mandatory work reporting to Medicaid expansion eligibility nationwide, with most states required to comply by January 1, 2027, under the text of the enacted law. Nebraska chose to volunteer as the test case. Six months in, the test case is producing exactly the kind of casualties critics warned about, and the state's own data shows why.

What the numbers actually show

Nebraska's Department of Health and Human Services describes the launch as a success, citing figures that the agency's work-requirements page and reporting on internal state data put at 86 percent of affected applicants either meeting the requirement or qualifying for an exemption, and 93 percent of existing enrollees retaining coverage. Those numbers are real, but they describe the share of people who navigated the system successfully, not the number who were hurt by it. By early July, according to internal documents obtained by KFF Health News, roughly 1,100 people had been denied benefits because of the work-reporting rules, and the state's own characterization of the dominant cause was not fraud or ineligibility but unsubmitted paperwork. Human Rights Watch, reviewing state figures released at the end of September, reported that more than 1,000 people lost or were denied Medicaid coverage between May and August because of the new rules, a toll the organization documented in a report on the rollout. Overall Medicaid enrollment in the affected population fell by about 4,600 people, a 1.4 percent drop, while call-center wait times nearly doubled, from roughly 13 minutes in May to 26 minutes in July, and call volume rose 66 percent by August. Nebraska budgeted $8.2 million over two years for outside contractors to build and run the verification system; at least six contracts exceeded $250,000, and one consultant's compensation topped $1.8 million, according to the KFF Health News reporting, which Nebraska Appleseed's program director, Sarah Maresh, called "shocking."

A preview, not an anomaly

None of this is particular to Nebraska's execution. It is the predictable output of a design that was debated and warned about before the law passed. The concerns raised on the first day of enforcement were about process, not politics: enrollees who already work or qualify for exemptions, including people with serious medical conditions or substance-use disorders, would still have to prove it through a bureaucracy that had never been built before and was being stood up on a compressed timeline with contracted call centers and new IT systems. Independent analyses of the reconciliation law's Medicaid provisions have long projected that the work-reporting requirement, not any change in who is legally eligible, would be the single largest driver of coverage loss nationally, a point KFF's analysis of the Congressional Budget Office's coverage estimates lays out in detail. That is the pattern Arkansas saw when it briefly tried work requirements in 2018: thousands of people lost coverage not because they failed to meet the underlying standard but because they failed to clear the reporting hurdle, often without knowing they needed to. Nebraska had the benefit of that history and still built a system where "unsubmitted paperwork" is the leading cause of termination seven months in.

"You're required to do work to stay on," a call-center representative told Eli McCreary, days after his kidney cancer diagnosis, according to his account to KFF Health News.

The McCreary case is instructive precisely because it is contested. Nebraska's spokesperson, Jeff Powell, insists the work requirement was never the actual cause of any lapse in his case. If that is true, it means a cancer patient still spent weeks believing a state bureaucracy had stripped his coverage over a work rule, acted on that belief by delaying cancer care, and was only sorted out after a reporter started asking questions. A system that produces that level of confusion for someone who was never supposed to be affected by the rule is not a system functioning as intended for the people who are. The design problem is structural: eligibility for an exemption, whether for illness, caregiving or treatment, still has to be affirmatively proven and processed by the same understaffed, high-turnover verification apparatus that is also fielding 80-hour-a-month work logs from tens of thousands of other enrollees.

Who is actually affected, and what should happen next

The honest case for work requirements rests on a theory of moral hazard: that some able-bodied adults are choosing not to work because Medicaid asks nothing of them. Nebraska's own figures undercut that theory in practice even as they are cited to support it. If 86 percent of applicants met the standard or qualified for an exemption on the first pass, the pool of people the policy is actually designed to move into the workforce is small, while the pool exposed to administrative risk is the full 70,000. The people falling through are disproportionately those least equipped to navigate a new bureaucracy under stress: patients in acute medical crises, people with substance-use histories, caregivers, and low-wage workers whose hours and documentation fluctuate month to month. That is not a side effect to be tolerated as the cost of weeding out fraud; it is the main effect, delivered to people the exemptions were written to protect.

More than 40 states face the same January 2027 deadline, with far larger Medicaid populations and, in many cases, less advance warning than Nebraska gave itself. Congress attached $200 million in one-time implementation funding nationally and the federal government typically covers up to 90 percent of state IT costs, but Nebraska's own contractor bills suggest that money will not stretch far once call centers, eligibility software and staffing are priced at national scale. Lawmakers who intend to let the mandate stand should treat Nebraska's call-wait times and paperwork-driven denials as an operating manual for what to fix before launch, not a public-relations problem to manage after the fact: simplified, pre-populated exemption verification for people with known diagnoses on file with Medicaid, meaningful advance notice before any termination, and independent audits of denial reasons, not just coverage-retention percentages. Congressional Democrats have said they want to repeal the work-reporting mandate in January, though a repeal would require overcoming a likely presidential veto. Short of repeal, the choice facing Washington and every state still building its system is whether to learn from Nebraska's first six months or to let the next 40 states discover the same gaps, one denied scan at a time.

More on this story

All Opinion