US Edition
Your source for latest news

Opinion: The Supreme Court Just Put a National Park Beyond the Law's Reach

A one-paragraph Supreme Court order clears bulldozers into Big Bend National Park by reading a 1996 border-security statute to put the Homeland Security Secretary's own environmental-law waivers almost entirely beyond judicial review.

PN
By PressTemps NewsroomPublished November 20, 2026 · 6 min read
Opinion: The Supreme Court Just Put a National Park Beyond the Law's Reach
Santa Elena Canyon, where the Rio Grande cuts between Texas and Mexico inside Big Bend National Park, part of the sector now reopened to border construction. Photo: Ralf Kiepert / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
What to know
On Nov. 9, 2026, the Supreme Court voted 8-1 per curiam in Mullin v. Friends of the Ruidosa Church to stay a federal injunction and let border-wall construction resume across Texas's Big Bend Sector, including inside Big Bend National Park.
The ruling holds that Section 102 of the 1996 IIRIRA, as amended by the 2005 REAL ID Act, bars courts from hearing any challenge to DHS border-construction waivers except on constitutional grounds, and that a major-questions-doctrine claim does not qualify as constitutional.
DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin's 2026 waivers, published in the Federal Register, suspended roughly two dozen federal statutes to allow barriers, roads and surveillance infrastructure through the park.
CBP's own published data show Big Bend Sector apprehensions fell about 74 percent between fiscal 2023 and fiscal 2025, to roughly 3,100 for the year, raising a real question about whether the sector even meets the statute's high-illegal-entry predicate for waiving the laws in the first place.

On November 9, the Supreme Court decided, in a single unsigned order, that construction could proceed through a national park before any judge is allowed to rule on whether that construction is lawful. The order came in Mullin v. Friends of the Ruidosa Church, an emergency application on the court's own docket over border-wall work in the Big Bend Sector of West Texas, and it passed 8-1, with only Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson noting she would have denied it. The practical effect is that U.S. Customs and Border Protection can resume cutting roads, barriers and surveillance infrastructure through Big Bend National Park and the Rio Grande's federally designated Wild and Scenic River corridor while a lawsuit challenging that work grinds on in a Texas courtroom — a lawsuit that, under the statute the Court just construed, may never reach a judge competent to rule on most of what is actually at stake.

This is not a dispute about whether the border should be more secure. It is a dispute about whether any court, anywhere, gets to check the government's own account of the facts and the law before a federally protected wilderness is reshaped for good.

A Waiver Clause Built to Outrun the Courts

Section 102 of the 1996 Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act lets the Homeland Security Secretary build border barriers "to deter illegal crossings in areas of high illegal entry." Since the 2005 REAL ID Act amended it, the same section lets the Secretary "waive all legal requirements" deemed necessary for "expeditious construction" — and then closes the courthouse door behind him. A challenge "may only be brought alleging a violation of the Constitution," the statute says, and federal courts "shall not have jurisdiction" over anything else. Congress even stripped the regional court of appeals — here, the Fifth Circuit — of jurisdiction to hear such claims at all, which is why the government's request to lift Judge Cardone's injunction went directly to the Supreme Court rather than through an ordinary appeal.

Secretary Markwayne Mullin, confirmed in March 2026 after Kristi Noem's resignation, invoked that authority repeatedly through the year to clear construction across the Big Bend Sector, a roughly 500-mile stretch of the Rio Grande that includes Big Bend National Park and Big Bend Ranch State Park. A string of Federal Register notices this year waived roughly two dozen federal statutes, among them, according to the Center for Biological Diversity, one of the plaintiffs, the National Park Service Organic Act, the Endangered Species Act and the National Wild and Scenic Rivers Act. "The absolute disdain this administration has for our national parks is disgraceful," the group's Laiken Jordahl said when the waiver covering the park itself was announced in June. By August, contractors were already clearing desert habitat near Santa Elena Canyon.

The One Argument the Court Just Closed Off

A river guide named Billy Miller, the historic-preservation group Friends of the Ruidosa Church, and the Center for Biological Diversity sued in the Western District of Texas, arguing among other things that the waivers violated the "major questions doctrine" — the principle that agencies need clear congressional authorization before deciding issues of vast economic or political significance. They framed the claim as constitutional, the only kind the statute lets a court hear. U.S. District Judge Kathleen Cardone agreed the theory cleared that bar and, on October 2, enjoined construction across the entire sector.

The Supreme Court's per curiam opinion dismantled that workaround in a few paragraphs.

"There is no such thing as a 'constitutional' major-questions claim."

The major-questions doctrine, the Court explained in its per curiam opinion, is a tool for interpreting statutes, not a freestanding constitutional guarantee; dressing a statutory-authority argument in constitutional language does not make it one. That reasoning is not obviously wrong as a matter of doctrine. It is, however, the last procedural door available to anyone who wants a federal court to examine whether a Cabinet secretary's own "high illegal entry" finding is accurate, or whether a waiver is truly "necessary" rather than merely convenient. Congress wrote the statute so that almost nothing else qualifies, and the Court has now confirmed it meant what it said.

Whose Harm Counts as Irreparable

The order did not stop at jurisdiction. It also weighed the equities and found them one-sided: the government said the injunction was costing it close to half a million dollars a day that could never be recovered, and the Court held that Congress had already decided, as a matter of policy, that expeditious construction outweighs "aesthetic, recreational, and environmental harm." Courts of equity, it wrote, cannot second-guess the balance Congress struck.

That framing treats two very different kinds of loss as interchangeable. Construction costs are recoverable in the ordinary sense that money is fungible; a desert ecosystem bulldozed along one of the last free-flowing stretches of the Rio Grande, inside a Wild and Scenic River corridor, near a 19th-century adobe church, is not. Nor is it obvious the sector even meets the statute's predicate. By Customs and Border Protection's own published numbers, the Big Bend Sector has long been among the least-crossed stretches of the entire southern border, and apprehensions there fell roughly 74 percent between fiscal 2023 and fiscal 2025, to about 3,100 for the full year — a fraction of what busier sectors record in a single month. A statute aimed at "areas of high illegal entry" is being used to fast-track construction through one of the quietest.

None of that got adjudicated, and under the Court's reading of the statute, none of it could. The entire dispute was resolved on the emergency docket: no merits briefing, no argument, a five-page unsigned opinion, one sentence recording a dissent with no reasoning attached. By the time any petition for certiorari is filed, briefed and decided — if one ever is — the roads and barriers will likely already stand. A stay of a preliminary injunction has become, in substance, the final word.

A Narrower Fix Is Available

None of this requires concluding that border barriers are never warranted, or that Congress lacked the power to limit frivolous litigation over them. It does mean Congress wrote a waiver clause broad enough to let the executive branch override statutes enacted specifically to protect one of the last wild river canyons in Texas — an outcome few members of the 1996 Congress likely anticipated applying to a unit of the National Park System whose protections trace back to the park's founding legislation in 1944. A narrower fix exists: Congress could amend Section 102(c) to exclude designated units of the National Park System, Wild and Scenic River segments and documented cultural sites from the waiver, while leaving the rest of the authority intact. Short of that, the next time a Cabinet secretary invokes "high illegal entry" to justify waiving dozens of statutes in a sector where crossings have been falling for years, some court ought to be able to ask whether that finding is true. Under Mullin, as the statute now stands, essentially none can.

More on this story

All Opinion