Opinion: The Senate's permitting deal is worth passing — after it fixes its tribal rights problem
The Senate's bipartisan permitting overhaul addresses a real, well-documented backlog in grid and project approvals, but its rewrite of tribal consultation rules under the National Historic Preservation Act is an avoidable flaw lawmakers should amend, not wave through or use as grounds to kill the whole bill.
The Senate did something this week it has not managed in more than a decade: it moved, with real bipartisan votes, toward rewriting the federal permitting rules that govern almost every power line, pipeline, mine and data center in the country. On Monday, senators voted 73-25 to end debate on the motion to proceed to the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, using H.R. 2347 as the legislative vehicle, and a day later voted 62-21 to formally take up the bill. A final floor vote could come within days. That rare alignment — Shelley Moore Capito and Mike Lee working with Sheldon Whitehouse and Martin Heinrich, the White House formally endorsing the text, and well over a thousand outside groups on record in support — reflects how badly both parties now want this done. They are right that the system is broken. They are wrong to let one title of the bill solve that problem by rolling back tribal nations' consultation rights, and the Senate should fix that title before it sends the bill anywhere near the president's desk.
A permitting deal years in the making
The case for urgency is not invented. The White House Council on Environmental Quality's own January 2025 accounting found that environmental impact statements completed between 2021 and 2024 took a median of 2.4 years just to get from a notice of intent to a final document, with a long tail of reviews stretching past six years. Grid connections are worse: Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory's latest interconnection-queue analysis shows the typical wait from a request to actually plugging a power plant into the grid has roughly doubled, from under two years for projects built in the early 2000s to more than four years for projects completed since 2018, at the same moment data-center demand is straining transmission capacity nationwide. Senate backers of the bill, citing the National Association of Manufacturers, put the annual cost of permitting delay to manufacturers at $12.1 billion, and the White House's own economists estimate the legislation could add $82 billion to $164 billion a year in output, according to the Environment and Public Works Committee's summary of the bill released alongside the cloture vote.
The bill itself, formally introduced as S. 5653 by Capito, Whitehouse, Lee and Heinrich on September 30, runs to nearly 500 pages across two divisions. One rewrites timelines and judicial-review standards under the National Environmental Policy Act, the Clean Water Act and the Endangered Species Act. The other reforms the Federal Power Act and, notably, includes a Ratepayer Protection Act provision requiring data centers to pay for their own power infrastructure rather than spreading the cost across ordinary utility customers. As Senate Environment and Public Works Chairwoman Capito put it in floor remarks accompanying the vote:
"The environmental permitting and review processes should be tools for informed decision-making, not reasons that decisions can't be made."
That is a defensible description of what NEPA has become in practice, and it is why the bill drew votes from senators who agree on almost nothing else.
Who actually has a stake in this
The constituencies pulling for and against this bill are broader than the usual partisan split:
- Renewable-energy and transmission developers, who have pushed for interconnection reform for years because long queues delay wind, solar and storage projects as much as pipelines.
- Data-center operators and the utilities serving them, who need faster approvals for substations and transmission lines to keep pace with AI-driven electricity demand.
- Manufacturers and fossil-fuel producers, whose trade groups have lobbied hardest for the NEPA and Clean Water Act changes.
- Tribal nations, who are not opposed to faster permitting in the abstract but say one title of this specific bill would weaken their legal standing in reviews of projects that cross or affect their lands and sacred sites.
The clause that should give the Senate pause
That last group's objection deserves to be taken seriously rather than waved off as an obstacle to progress. Nine tribal organizations, in an October 9 letter coordinated by the Native American Rights Fund, argued that the bill's rewrite of Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act would narrow the window for government-to-government consultation, curtail tribes' access to the courts, and effectively make early consultation optional rather than required before a project's design is largely locked in. The National Congress of American Indians, joined by the Association on American Indian Affairs, the National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers and the United South and Eastern Tribes Sovereignty Protection Fund, issued a similar joint statement defending the existing Section 106 process. Their argument is not sentimental. Section 106 exists because federal projects have repeatedly damaged burial grounds and sacred sites that were identified too late in a process tribes learned about only after the fact; consultation that arrives after an environmental assessment is substantially written is not meaningful consultation, it is notification. On the Senate floor, that skepticism has real votes behind it: Nevada's Catherine Cortez Masto backed the procedural motion but has said she will vote against final passage unless this title changes, and Majority Leader Schumer has said he has "outstanding concerns" he intends to press through amendments.
Amend it, do not abandon it
The honest answer is that both sides have a real case, and the bill does not have to choose between them. The economic argument for faster permitting rests overwhelmingly on NEPA timelines, interconnection queues and duplicative federal-state review — not on the historic-preservation consultation process that Title III targets. The Institute for Progress's own analysis of the bill's tribal-consultation provisions acknowledges this is a genuinely contested slice of the package, not a load-bearing one for the headline economic numbers Capito's committee is citing. That means the Senate can fix Section 106 — restoring earlier, binding consultation windows and preserving judicial review — without touching the deadlines and interagency-coordination reforms that address the delays CEQ and Berkeley Lab actually documented. Even the National Tribal Energy Association, which has told Senate leaders the broader bill "takes meaningful steps to honor our Tribal sovereignty and self-determination," is not asking senators to choose between speed and consultation — a middle path Senate negotiators should take up this week rather than treating Section 106 as a bargaining chip to be traded away for a few more Republican votes.
Killing the bill outright, as some environmental groups are now urging, would be a mistake: the backlog this legislation targets is real, measurable and getting worse as electricity demand climbs, and no realistic alternative vehicle is waiting in the wings this Congress. But passing it with Title III intact, over the explicit objection of the tribal nations whose consultation rights it rewrites, would trade one set of government dysfunction for another kind of government bad faith. The Senate has the votes and the days left this week to amend the historic-preservation title before a final vote. It should use them, and send the House a bill that speeds up the grid without cutting tribal nations out of decisions about their own land.
Opinion: Washington wants its own rules for killer robots, not the world's

Opinion: Amazon's new Bond is a bet against the safe choice

Opinion: Europe Wrote a Migration Pact for Moments Like This. Spain Won't Use It.
