Senate clears key hurdle on bill ending IRS tax bite for sexual-abuse survivors
A bipartisan bill that would let survivors of sexual abuse keep civil settlements and judgments free of federal income tax, even without proof of physical injury, moved a step closer to final passage after the Senate voted Monday night to limit debate on a Republican substitute.

The Senate voted 70-27 on Monday evening to invoke cloture on a substitute amendment to the Survivor Justice Tax Prevention Act, clearing a key procedural hurdle for a bill that would exempt most civil settlements and court judgments won by sexual-abuse survivors from federal income tax. The vote, recorded as Roll Call Vote 264 of the Senate's second session, cuts off further debate on an amendment offered by Sen. Shelley Moore Capito, R-W.Va., and sets up a final vote on the underlying bill, known formally as H.R. 2347.
The measure already passed the House by voice vote in April. If the Senate adopts it with Capito's changes, the House would need to vote again to agree to the Senate's version before it could go to President Donald Trump's desk.
A bill that has moved in bipartisan steps
The bill's path through the Senate this month has been marked by lopsided bipartisan votes. On Nov. 9, the chamber voted 73-25 to invoke cloture on the motion to proceed to the bill. The next day, senators voted 62-21 to formally take it up. Monday's 70-27 vote on the Capito substitute keeps that pattern of broad, if not unanimous, support. None of the three roll calls has broken cleanly along party lines, and the Senate has not yet scheduled the final up-or-down vote on passage.
In the House, the bill moved just as smoothly. The Ways and Means Committee approved it by a 41-0 vote on March 25, according to a committee summary, before the full chamber passed it without objection the following month. Its chief sponsors are Rep. Lloyd Smucker, R-Pa., and Rep. Gwen Moore, D-Wis., an unusual pairing of a conservative tax writer and a progressive Democrat who has focused much of her legislative career on domestic violence and sexual assault.
Closing a gap in the tax code
The bill addresses a narrow but consequential feature of the federal tax code. Under Section 104(a)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code, damages received in a lawsuit or settlement are generally excluded from a recipient's taxable income only if they stem from a "physical injury or physical sickness." That standard, tightened by Congress in 1996, has left many survivors of sexual abuse exposed to federal income tax on settlement money, because the harm they describe is frequently psychological rather than visibly physical. The Ways and Means one-pager notes that survivors "often do not have the same observable, documented physical injuries" as plaintiffs in other personal-injury cases, a gap that tax attorneys and victims' advocates have flagged for years as settlements from clergy-abuse cases, university athletics scandals and workplace harassment claims have multiplied.
H.R. 2347 would not touch the physical-injury requirement generally. Instead it adds a specific carve-out for damages "received on account of" a sexual act or unwanted sexual contact, borrowing definitions from existing federal criminal law. Key features of the bill include:
- Excludes most settlement and judgment income tied to sexual abuse from gross income, while leaving punitive damages taxable as before.
- Removes the need for medical records or evidence of visible physical injury to qualify for the exclusion.
- Shifts the burden onto the IRS, rather than the survivor, to show that a settlement was not related to sexual abuse once a court record or settlement agreement identifies it as such.
- Applies only to settlements and judgments reached after the law takes effect, with an anti-abuse provision barring parties from backdating agreements to qualify.
Who the change would affect
Because the exclusion is not retroactive, it would apply going forward to a large and growing pool of litigation: ongoing clergy-abuse settlements working through state compensation funds and bankruptcy proceedings, continuing civil claims tied to sports organizations such as USA Gymnastics, and the steady stream of workplace sexual-harassment and assault settlements that follow #MeToo-era changes to state statutes of limitations. Plaintiffs' attorneys have long argued that taxing this category of damages compounds the financial burden on survivors, since settlements are frequently structured to cover years of therapy, lost wages and legal fees rather than a one-time windfall.
Smucker has framed the bill in those terms since introducing it with Moore.
"Physical injury doesn't always reflect the unimaginable trauma survivors endure," Smucker said of the legislation, adding that it "ensures survivors of sexual assault receive justice — not a tax bill from the IRS."
Moore has described the bill in similar language, calling it "a major step toward securing tax parity for survivors of abuse," while Ways and Means Chairman Jason Smith, R-Mo., has pointed to the same evidentiary gap that leaves many survivors unable to claim the existing physical-injury exclusion.
What happens next
The Senate's cloture vote Monday does not itself change the tax code. It merely ends debate on Capito's substitute language, which Senate aides have described as a version negotiated to address technical concerns raised during earlier committee work on the bill. A separate vote to adopt that substitute, followed by a vote on final passage, would still be required before the bill could leave the Senate. Those votes had not been scheduled as of Tuesday morning.
If the Senate passes the amended bill, it returns to the House, which would need to agree to the Senate's changes before the measure could be sent to the White House. Congressional aides have not said whether the bill will get a stand-alone vote or be attached to one of the year-end funding or tax packages lawmakers are expected to negotiate before current government funding lapses in mid-December. The Senate's broader calendar for the rest of the lame-duck session, including judicial nominations and that funding deadline, is likely to compete for floor time with any final vote on the survivor-tax measure.
Neither Smucker's office nor Senate leadership offices have set a target date for final Senate passage. A Congressional Budget Office cost estimate was produced in April, when the bill moved through the House, though the office's full analysis of the revenue effects was not independently reviewed for this article.
Democrat edges out House Rules Committee chair in tight North Carolina recount race

White House warns incoming Democratic Congress that oversight could cross into 'blatant criminality'
Senate Republicans race to confirm Trump's judges before Democrats take control
