US Edition
Your source for latest news
ScienceOcean science

Thousands of tiny animals found living inside deep-sea mining's target rocks

A new study of 244 Pacific seafloor nodules found more than 4,100 worms, crustaceans and other organisms wedged into their cracks, raising fresh questions about biodiversity loss as companies push toward commercial deep-sea mining.

PS
By PressTemps Science DeskPublished Today, 14:20 ET · 5 min read
Thousands of tiny animals found living inside deep-sea mining's target rocks
Photo: Patlack / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 — Polymetallic nodules from the Pacific Ocean's Clarion-Clipperton Zone (illustrative stock image; not the specific nodules examined in this study).
What to know
A new Scientific Reports study found 4,139 animals living inside the cracks of 244 deep-sea polymetallic nodules from the Pacific's Clarion-Clipperton Zone
Nodules held an average of 17 animals each, with one rock sheltering 245; bigger nodules had more and wider internal cracks
Genetic testing found the nodule-dwelling communities of nematodes and copepods differ consistently from animals in the surrounding sediment, despite being similar across distances of 1,000 kilometers
Because nodules take millions of years to form, researchers warn commercial mining in the zone could permanently erase this undescribed biodiversity before it is even catalogued

Fist-sized rocks scattered across the Pacific seafloor, and prized by mining companies for the nickel, cobalt and copper locked inside them, turn out to double as apartment blocks for thousands of tiny animals, according to a study published this month in Scientific Reports. Researchers who cracked open 244 polymetallic nodules from the Clarion-Clipperton Zone found nearly 4,200 worms, crustaceans and single-celled organisms wedged into the rocks' internal cracks — a previously overlooked habitat that complicates plans to mine the seabed on an industrial scale.

The nodules themselves are nothing new to science. These dark, potato-shaped lumps of iron and manganese oxide carpet vast stretches of abyssal seafloor between Hawaii and Mexico, growing only a few millimeters every million years as metals precipitate out of seawater around a tiny core, such as a shark's tooth or bone fragment. What is new is the discovery of what lives inside them.

A world inside the rock

A team led by Coral Diaz-Recio Lorenzo, now at France's Roscoff Biological Research Station, and Tanja Stratmann of MARUM, the University of Bremen's marine sciences center, dissected nodules collected by box corer and remotely operated vehicle from depths of roughly 4,000 to 6,000 meters. Sorting through the cracks and pores of each rock, they extracted 4,139 individual animals — mostly microscopic nematode worms and copepod crustaceans, along with shelled amoeba-like foraminifera. On average a nodule held 17 residents; the most crowded single rock yielded 245.

The numbers scaled with size: each time a nodule's volume doubled, the team calculated, the number of animals living inside it rose by about 34%, and their combined biomass rose by nearly 33%. Bigger nodules also had wider internal cracks, which the researchers measured growing roughly 15% in diameter with each doubling in volume — more room, it turns out, for more tenants.

Genetic barcoding of the specimens, using the 18S ribosomal RNA gene, turned up 22 likely nematode species and 83 likely copepod species living in the nodules — many of them undescribed. Oddly, the communities inside nodules collected as much as 1,000 kilometers apart looked genetically similar to one another, yet consistently different from the worms and crustaceans living in the soft sediment just centimeters away. One single-celled organism, a foraminiferan called Thurammina sp. 1, showed up again and again inside nodules and almost nowhere else, suggesting it has adapted specifically to crevice life.

Fewer animals, but ones found nowhere else

In absolute terms, nodules are sparsely populated compared with the mud around them: nematode numbers inside the rocks ran to roughly a tenth of sediment densities, and copepods to about a quarter. But the species composition was distinct enough that habitat alone — nodule versus sediment — explained more than a tenth of the genetic variation among both groups, a substantial figure for communities living just inches apart on the same patch of seafloor.

That distinction matters because of where these nodules sit in the world. The Clarion-Clipperton Zone holds the largest known reserves of seabed nodules on Earth, and it is the focus of most of the exploration activity overseen by the International Seabed Authority, the United Nations-affiliated body that governs mineral activity in international waters. The authority has issued 31 exploration contracts to 21 contractors, 19 of them specifically for polymetallic nodules, though no commercial extraction has yet been approved while rules for full-scale mining remain in draft. The two sets of nodules analyzed in the new study came from exploration areas licensed to Germany's federal geosciences institute and to the Belgian contractor Global Sea Mineral Resources — demonstrating that the crevice-dwelling communities exist squarely inside the zones companies hope to mine.

A habitat that can't grow back

The stakes of that overlap come down to timescales. A nodule the size of a potato can take millions of years to form. Mining machinery now being tested would strip nodules from the seafloor in a single pass, and any resulting loss of the animals living inside them would be, for practical purposes, permanent on any timeline relevant to conservation or industry.

"Commercial mining may result in an irreversible loss of undescribed and unique biodiversity," said Sabine Gollner, a professor at the Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research and one of the study's senior authors.

Stratmann said the cracks inside the nodules "are large enough to provide a home to animals," while Diaz-Recio Lorenzo described the crevices as functioning like "small shelters" for species rarely, if ever, encountered in the surrounding mud. Their findings echo and extend earlier work by Stratmann's group showing that nodule removal would simplify deep-sea food webs across the Clarion-Clipperton Zone, and align with a parallel 2024 NIOZ-led study that found unexpectedly high biodiversity around nodule fields and hydrothermal vents more broadly, as Ocean News reported this week.

What happens next

The authors are careful to note that their survey, while the largest of its kind, cannot yet say whether losing nodules in one mined area would drive any of these species to true extinction, or whether they persist in unsampled patches of seafloor elsewhere in the 4.5-million-square-kilometer Clarion-Clipperton Zone — one of several open questions the paper flags for follow-up work. Stratmann is currently on a research expedition back to the zone to gather more samples, and the wider international JPI Oceans "MiningImpact" program, which has funded much of this line of research, is continuing to monitor test-mining sites for longer-term ecological recovery.

For regulators, the practical upshot is that environmental baselines for deep-sea mining permits may need to account for organisms invisible to the naked eye and easy to miss in standard seafloor surveys, not just the sponges, corals and larger fauna that have dominated public debate over mining the ocean floor. With the International Seabed Authority still finalizing exploitation rules for commercial-scale nodule mining, the newly documented crevice communities are likely to feature in the scientific advice feeding into that process, adding a layer of biodiversity that, until this study, had gone essentially uncounted.

More on this story

All Science