US Edition
Your source for latest news
USCourts

Judge Again Blocks Trump Plan to Close Washington Golf Course, Opens Ethics Inquiry

A federal judge halted the National Park Service's plan to shut down a historic public golf course near the White House for a championship-style overhaul, the latest setback in a nine-month legal fight now also probing whether government lawyers misled the court.

PW
By PressTemps Washington DeskPublished Today, 12:42 ET · 6 min read
Judge Again Blocks Trump Plan to Close Washington Golf Course, Opens Ethics Inquiry
File photo. The clubhouse at East Potomac Golf Course, photographed in 2013. Photo: Tim Evanson / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0
What to know
A federal judge on November 14 blocked the National Park Service from closing East Potomac Golf Course in Washington through at least November 28, pending a lawsuit over the Trump administration's renovation plans.
The case followed an October incident in which the Park Service felled 529 trees at the course in a single day on roughly 12 hours' notice, according to the plaintiffs' emergency court filing.
The same judge, Ana Reyes, has moved to appoint a former U.S. attorney, Jessie Liu, as a special master to investigate whether government officials or lawyers misled the court about the project's scope.
The Trump administration has vowed to appeal and says the renovation, led by golf architect Tom Fazio, is meant to produce a venue capable of hosting a major tournament; the government's earlier appeal of a related injunction is still pending at the D.C. Circuit.

A federal judge in Washington handed the Trump administration a fresh setback over the weekend in its drive to convert a public golf course two miles from the White House into a championship-caliber venue, temporarily blocking the National Park Service from closing East Potomac Park and its golf course ahead of a planned 15-month renovation. The order, issued Saturday, November 14, by U.S. District Judge Ana C. Reyes, keeps the 106-year-old waterfront park open to the public through at least November 28, and arrives as the same judge pursues a separate inquiry into whether government officials and lawyers misled her about the administration's plans.

President Trump, who toured the site with Interior Secretary Doug Burgum earlier this year and has pushed for the redesign, said on social media that the administration would "immediately appeal, on an expedited basis," and offered Washington-area residents a 50 percent discount on green fees once the course reopens. He called the ruling "highly destructive and political."

What the order does, and does not do

Reyes's order bars the Park Service from closing East Potomac Park or its golf course during their normal public hours while the underlying lawsuit continues, but it does not force the agency to keep golf actually being played there, leaving open whether the course's current operator can keep functioning in the meantime. The judge wrote that Trump's own social media posts "indicate that the Washington National Plan is final" and that the Park Service intended to close the park to carry it out — evidence she said undercut the government's stated justification for the closure.

A fight that began with 529 felled trees

The case dates to February, when the DC Preservation League and two local golfers, Dave Roberts and Alex Dickson, sued the Interior Department, Secretary Burgum and the Park Service, arguing that plans to remake East Potomac violated federal environmental and administrative law. The dispute escalated in October, when, according to an emergency court filing by the plaintiffs, the Park Service gave barely 12 hours' notice before a crew felled 529 trees at the golf course in a single day over the Columbus Day holiday weekend, with officials confirming plans to take down hundreds more.

Reyes responded with a preliminary injunction barring further tree removal and requiring 10 business days' written notice before any further irreversible changes to the park. The Justice Department appealed that ruling to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit but did not ask for a stay, so the restrictions have remained in force. At a later hearing, Reyes grew skeptical of the government's account of its plans, telling lawyers, according to reporting on the case, that "rarely, if ever" has the Justice Department asked a federal court not to believe the sitting president.

The current fight over the course has roots in a 2020 agreement: after a competitive bidding process that the Park Service announced that June, the agency selected the nonprofit National Links Trust to take over the city's three public golf courses and later signed a 50-year lease committing the operator to keep East Potomac, Langston and Rock Creek Park courses "affordable" and accessible to seniors, veterans, people with disabilities and new golfers. The Park Service ended that arrangement for East Potomac late last year as the administration moved toward a redesign by golf architect Tom Fazio intended to draw a PGA major or a Ryder Cup.

Who is affected, and the ethics questions still unresolved

The fight pits a White House ambition to build a marquee golf venue against preservationists, joggers and cyclists who use the park's Ohio Drive loop, and golfers who rely on East Potomac as one of the region's more affordable public courses. A Justice Department attorney, Adam Gustafson, told the court the planned closure of the broader park — which also includes a miniature golf course — was driven by safety concerns tied to staffing and an expiring operating lease. Reyes found that explanation did not hold up, noting that safety had not come up in months of closure discussions beforehand.

The Washington National Plan is final, and the National Park Service will close the park to implement it.

That skepticism has fed into a parallel track in the case. On November 7, Reyes said she intended to appoint Jessie Liu, a former U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia, as a special master to examine whether Interior Department, Park Service or Justice Department officials violated ethics rules or misled the court about the scope of the renovation and the tree removal, according to reporting on the order. The government has objected to the appointment and separately asked that Reyes remove herself from the case, a request she has not granted.

What's next

The restraining order issued Saturday runs only through November 28 unless the court acts sooner, and it is unclear whether the administration can immediately appeal it, since such orders are generally not subject to immediate review. The government's appeal of the earlier preliminary injunction remains pending before the D.C. Circuit, according to court filings in that case, and the special master's ethics review has not been completed. Meanwhile, coverage of the weekend ruling by the Boston Globe and the Philadelphia Inquirer notes that the Park Service has not said when, or whether, it will attempt the closure again once the current order lapses.

More on this story

All US