Democrat Mary Peltola flips Alaska Senate seat as Justice Department presses on with court fight
Mary Peltola's defeat of two-term Sen. Dan Sullivan hands Democrats a 56th Senate seat, but the result remains unofficial while the Justice Department appeals a dismissed lawsuit and pursues a separate criminal inquiry tied to a second candidate who shared the incumbent's name.

Democrat Mary Peltola has defeated two-term Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan in Alaska, a flip that moves the incoming Senate to a 56-44 Democratic majority and closes out the most consequential Senate map Republicans have had to defend in more than a decade. The Associated Press called the race Tuesday night, but the result remains officially unsettled: Sullivan has not conceded, and a Justice Department lawsuit seeking to delay certification of the outcome is still alive on appeal.
The Alaska seat was the last of this year's Senate races to be decided, and it arrived tangled in a legal fight that has run in parallel with the vote count since before Election Day. A federal judge threw out the Justice Department's suit on November 1, but the department appealed within the hour, and a separate federal criminal investigation into the circumstances of the race continues with no charges filed.
A race decided, but not yet certified
With roughly 99 percent of ballots counted, Peltola led with 50.1 percent of first-choice votes to Sullivan's 45.8 percent, a margin of about 12,500 votes, according to state figures cited by the Anchorage Daily News. Because Peltola cleared the 50 percent threshold, Alaska's ranked-choice system did not require a second round of tabulation for the Senate contest, unlike several other races on the same ballot.
The outcome stays unofficial until the state finishes its process. The Alaska Division of Elections' general election results page still labels the Senate tally "unofficial," and the division's own election calendar lists November 25 as the target date for certification, following a review by the State Review Board and a hand-count verification of precincts. Either candidate can request a recount within five days of certification; the state covers the cost only if the margin is under half a percentage point, which this one is not.
Sullivan's campaign has said it will not concede before certification. "We're going to let the process run its course until every legal vote is counted and certified," spokesman Nate Adams said. Peltola, who would become the first Alaska Native elected to the Senate, told supporters the result reflected frustration with Washington: "The status quo in D.C. is not working for Alaska."
Two Dan Sullivans on one ballot
The race was complicated for months by the presence of a second candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan, a retired Petersburg schoolteacher with no party affiliation who advanced through Alaska's top-four primary alongside the incumbent, Sen. Dan S. Sullivan. State election officials initially tried to keep the newcomer off the ballot over concerns about voter confusion; Alaska courts overruled them, and Lt. Gov. Nancy Dahlstrom's office opened an inquiry in June into whether his filing was coordinated with another campaign.
A New York Times report published days before the election alleged, based on documents and interviews with a former Peltola campaign manager, that Democratic operatives helped recruit the second Sullivan to split votes from the incumbent. Peltola has denied any knowledge of or involvement in the effort, and Daniel J. Sullivan has denied contact with her campaign. The allegation nonetheless became the basis for the federal government's legal and criminal response to the race.
A dismissed lawsuit, and an investigation that outlasted it
At President Trump's direction, the Justice Department sued the Alaska Division of Elections on October 22, asking a federal court to block certification of the Senate result if Sullivan lost, to segregate ballots cast for his namesake, and to allow an investigation into those voters before any result became final. U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the suit on November 1, ruling that the government lacked standing because it could not show how its proposed remedy — separating and investigating specific ballots — could be carried out without violating Alaska voters' right to a secret ballot. She called the relief the department sought "infeasible" and denied it leave to amend. The department filed notice of appeal to the Ninth Circuit the same afternoon, and that appeal remains pending.
"This is voter fraud at the highest level."
That was President Trump's characterization of the race after the ruling, part of a running public demand that Peltola be removed from the ballot and prosecuted. The Justice Department has separately confirmed a criminal investigation exists into the circumstances of Daniel J. Sullivan's candidacy, though prosecutors in Alaska have declined to specify what statutes are under review. Federal agents have reportedly sought records from donors connected to the second Sullivan's campaign.
Alaska's state attorneys, who defended against the civil suit alongside Peltola's campaign, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, and the League of Women Voters of Alaska, argued the ballot itself was designed to minimize confusion — it listed the incumbent as "Dan S. Sullivan," labeled "Incumbent" and "Registered Republican," with no comparable labels for his namesake. They called the federal demand to set aside votes "not even possible" given ballot-secrecy protections. Gov. Mike Dunleavy, who separately ordered a state investigation into the second Sullivan's recruitment, has said he will not commit to certifying a Peltola win, though election-law specialists note that certification authority rests with the Division of Elections director, not the governor.
What happens next
Several deadlines now run in parallel. Alaska's State Review Board began examining election materials on November 19 and will conduct a hand-count verification of precincts later this week. If certification proceeds on schedule November 25, either campaign would have until November 30 to request a recount and until December 5 to challenge the result in state superior court. Peltola's six-year term would not begin until the new Congress convenes on January 3, 2027; until then, Sullivan remains Alaska's junior senator.
- Peltola's win is the ninth Republican-held Senate seat to flip to Democrats this cycle, the party's best Senate showing since 1958.
- The Ninth Circuit has not set a briefing schedule indicating it intends to act quickly on the Justice Department's appeal.
- No one has been charged in the federal criminal investigation into the second Sullivan candidacy.
For Senate Democrats, the practical stakes of the outstanding litigation are limited, since Senate seating rules operate separately from a state's own certification disputes. The more immediate question is whether the Ninth Circuit moves before the new Congress convenes, and whether the pending criminal investigation produces any findings before Alaska's government changes hands on December 7, when Dunleavy's term ends.

DHS secretary grilled over football flight as FBI's Patel again skips threat hearing

Trump's pick to run Congress's watchdog agency faces hearing amid bipartisan-process complaints

Ecuadorean fishing crew sues Trump administration over Pacific drone strike
