US Edition
Your source for latest news
PoliticsWar Powers

Ecuadorean fishing crew sues Trump administration over Pacific drone strike

Sixteen fishermen say an unexplained drone attack sank their boat in March and that U.S. forces held them for weeks afterward, adding to a stack of lawsuits challenging a strike campaign that has reportedly killed well over 200 people.

PW
By PressTemps Washington DeskPublished Today, 17:08 ET · 5 min read
Ecuadorean fishing crew sues Trump administration over Pacific drone strike
An MQ-9 Reaper, the type of U.S. military drone used in the campaign against suspected drug-trafficking vessels. File photo from 2007; not the aircraft involved in the strike described in this story. Photo: U.S. Air Force / Staff Sgt. Brian Ferguson, public domain, Wikimedia Commons
What to know
Sixteen Ecuadorean fishermen sued the Trump administration in federal court in Pittsburgh over a March drone strike that destroyed their boat and burned two crew members
The lawsuit alleges the U.S. has carried out 71 strikes on boats in the Pacific and Caribbean since September 2025, killing at least 235 people
The suit follows a January wrongful-death case brought by relatives of two Trinidadian men killed in an earlier strike, and repeated Senate votes to limit the strikes under the War Powers Resolution have failed
The Defense Department declined to comment on the pending litigation, and the White House and Justice Department did not respond to requests for comment

Sixteen Ecuadorean fishermen filed a federal lawsuit against the Trump administration this week, alleging that a U.S. military drone attack destroyed their boat in the eastern Pacific in March, burned two of the crew, and was followed by an abduction and weeks of mistreatment at the hands of American forces. The suit, filed Monday in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania in Pittsburgh, is the latest and largest legal challenge yet to the Trump administration's campaign of lethal strikes on vessels it says are tied to drug trafficking in the Caribbean and eastern Pacific.

The complaint, brought by the crew of the fishing vessel Negra Francisca Duarte II and reported by Common Dreams and in a Reuters wire dispatch, says two armed drones struck the boat roughly 385 nautical miles off Ecuador's coast while it was returning from a two-week fishing expedition. Ecuadorean authorities had inspected the vessel shortly before the attack and found no drugs or evidence of cartel ties, according to the filing. The crew says it jumped into the water as the boat burned, was intercepted by armed men in military-style uniforms, and was eventually transported for seven days aboard a ship to a port in El Salvador before being returned to Ecuador weeks later.

A widening toll

The lawsuit puts a number on a campaign that has drawn mounting scrutiny since it began: it alleges the United States has carried out 71 strikes on boats in the Pacific and Caribbean since September 2025, killing at least 235 people. That figure has climbed steadily in official and congressional accounting. In a statement describing a Senate vote to block a related war-powers resolution, Senator Adam Schiff's office cited roughly 200 people killed in the strikes, "with more strikes every week," according to the senator's office. The military campaign, known as Operation Southern Spear, has also swept up fishermen without killing them. Between late August and mid-September, U.S. Southern Command announced it had intercepted and sunk at least eight Ecuadorean vessels in the Pacific, describing them in a series of releases as floating "refueling" stations supporting the Los Choneros criminal organization. One such Southern Command press release describes Marines and sailors boarding and searching a vessel before it was sunk. Those eight boats carried roughly 160 crew members; according to Human Rights Watch, 56 were later released by court order, 40 were acquitted for lack of evidence, 50 remain awaiting trial, and 14 were never formally charged with anything.

An operation built on disputed legal ground

Operation Southern Spear grew out of a campaign the Trump administration launched against suspected drug-trafficking vessels in September 2025, under the president's claimed Article II authority as commander in chief. The administration has maintained that the strikes do not constitute "hostilities" requiring congressional authorization under the War Powers Resolution, a position Democrats and a handful of Republicans have repeatedly challenged and lost on the Senate floor. In one such vote, Senator Tim Kaine's office said a resolution aimed at the boat strikes was blocked by a majority of Senate Republicans, with Kaine arguing in a statement that Congress alone holds the power to declare war.

The new lawsuit makes a parallel legal argument from a different angle, contending there was no armed conflict that could justify lethal military force against the boats and accusing the government of kidnapping and torture. The Washington Post has reported that some of the Pacific strikes on Ecuadorean vessels, including ones near the Galápagos Islands, were carried out under a CIA program rather than by the military, a detail that has complicated congressional oversight of the campaign. A Defense Department spokesperson declined to comment on the pending litigation, and the White House and Justice Department did not respond to requests for comment on the suit, according to the Reuters dispatch.

Fishermen caught in the middle

The plaintiffs are ordinary fishing crews, not accused traffickers, according to their attorney, Pittsburgh-based lawyer Dan Kovalik, who has filed several related cases against the administration's boat-strike campaign. He has said the loss of their boat left the men unable to work or support their families. The captain of the Negra Francisca Duarte II, Hernan Flores, said simply that the crew sued because the boat was all they had, and that no one in Ecuador was helping them.

"You can't go around the world trying to kill people and let impunity reign," said Jorge Chiriboga, a lawyer representing the fishermen.

The case follows a smaller but similarly framed suit filed in January in federal court in Massachusetts by relatives of two Trinidadian men killed in an earlier strike, which NPR reported was the first wrongful-death case over the strikes to reach a U.S. court. Separately, civil liberties groups have sought a Justice Department legal opinion underpinning the strikes through a Freedom of Information Act request, and relatives of a Colombian man killed in the campaign have filed a complaint with the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights naming Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth.

What comes next

The Pittsburgh case is likely to move slowly. Suits against the federal government over military and intelligence operations typically face early motions to dismiss on sovereign-immunity and political-question grounds, and the Trump administration has so far declined to disclose much about the legal basis for individual strikes, including the one on the Negra Francisca Duarte II. Lawmakers pushing to rein in the campaign have signaled they intend to keep forcing war-powers votes even after repeated defeats, betting that a rising death toll and a growing stack of lawsuits will eventually shift votes in a Senate where only a handful of Republicans have broken with the administration. For the sixteen fishermen named in Monday's filing, the more immediate question is simpler: whether a federal court will even agree to hear a case over a strike the government says it knows nothing about.

More on this story

All Politics