Divided appeals court rules House pandemic-era proxy votes unconstitutional
A 9-8 ruling from the full 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals found that the House violated the Constitution's quorum requirement by using proxy voting to help pass a $1.7 trillion spending bill in 2022, and it blocks enforcement of a pregnancy-accommodation law against Texas while the judges insist the holding is narrow.

A divided federal appeals court ruled Friday that the House of Representatives violated the Constitution when it used a pandemic-era proxy voting system to help pass a $1.7 trillion government funding bill in December 2022, striking down enforcement of part of that law in Texas even as the judges insisted their ruling was narrow.
The 9-8 decision from the full U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit, sitting en banc, found that the Constitution's Quorum Clause does not permit members of Congress to be counted toward a quorum unless they are physically present on the House floor. Because 226 of the 431 members who voted on the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 did so by proxy, the court held, the chamber never had a constitutional quorum when it passed the bill.
What the court decided
The case, State of Texas v. Blanche, No. 24-10386, was filed by the state of Texas against Attorney General Todd Blanche, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and its leadership. Texas did not ask the court to throw out the entire spending law. Instead, it sought to block enforcement against the state of just one provision tucked inside it: the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which requires employers to provide reasonable accommodations to pregnant workers.
Writing for the majority, Judge Cory T. Wilson, a Trump appointee joined by Chief Judge Jennifer Walker Elrod and seven other judges, said the Quorum Clause's text, historical practice and a Supreme Court precedent more than 125 years old all point the same way.
"Proxy presence does not count."
The ruling affirmed a 2024 decision by a federal district judge in the Northern District of Texas, who had already blocked the federal government from enforcing the pregnancy-accommodation law against the state. Judge James Graves, in a dissent joined by six other judges, called the majority's reasoning "illogical, inexplicable, and invalid," according to NBC News's account of the opinion, arguing that the Constitution's text does not require physical presence and questioning why the court limited its own holding to a single provision if its logic reached the law's validity as a whole. Judge Catharina Haynes filed a separate dissent, writing that she did not think it appropriate to "throw out" an action of the House but agreeing with much of Graves's reasoning.
A pandemic-era rule outlives the pandemic
The House adopted the proxy system in May 2020 through House Resolution 965, allowing members to designate a colleague to record their presence or cast their vote during the public health emergency, provided the absent member submitted a signed letter naming a proxy. Then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi and House Democrats renewed the practice repeatedly through 2022, and it remained in place when the chamber passed the omnibus spending package that December, just before Republicans took control of the House in January 2023. The new Republican majority ended the practice that same month.
The 4,000-plus-page Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 itself bundled twelve annual spending bills for the 2023 fiscal year along with emergency aid for Ukraine and domestic disaster relief, and it passed the House 225-201 on Dec. 23, 2022, before clearing the Senate and being signed into law by President Biden six days later.
Who is affected
The immediate, legally binding effect of Friday's ruling is confined to Texas: the Justice Department and the EEOC remain barred from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against the state as an employer, a status that has largely held since the district court's order. Legal commentators, including George Mason University law professor Jonathan Adler writing on the Volokh Conspiracy blog, noted that the same reasoning could in theory call into question any other provision of the 2022 law passed by the same proxy vote, including a ban on the TikTok app on government devices and a separate measure overhauling how Congress counts electoral votes. The majority opinion explicitly declined to go that far, confining its holding to the provision Texas challenged.
Workplace advocates who pushed for years to pass the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act have criticized the broader legal campaign against it since the district court's 2024 ruling, arguing it leaves pregnant state employees in Texas without a clear path to enforce accommodation rights available to workers elsewhere in the country. The EEOC's own guidance describes the law as requiring covered employers to provide reasonable accommodations, such as additional breaks or schedule changes, absent undue hardship.
Reaction and what comes next
The Justice Department, which inherited the defense of the case, did not immediately respond to the ruling, according to news accounts published Friday night. Texas brought the challenge under Attorney General Ken Paxton.
Adler and other legal observers were skeptical the decision will be the last word, predicting the federal government is likely to seek review from the full Supreme Court given the closeness of the en banc vote, the age and significance of the precedent at stake, and the dissent's argument that the Quorum Clause question may not even be the kind of dispute courts can resolve. No petition for Supreme Court review had been filed as of Friday night.
The ruling lands in the middle of a lame-duck congressional session already consumed by funding fights, leadership races and the aftermath of this month's midterm elections, and it is likely to renew debate in both parties over whether the House should preserve any version of remote participation for future emergencies.

Trump order requires federal contractors to clear congressional inquiries with the White House

Second Federal Judge Blocks Construction of Trump's 250-Foot Arch Near Arlington Cemetery

Trump ousts national cyber director as string of tech outages rattles Washington
