US Edition
Your source for latest news
PoliticsCourts

Second Federal Judge Blocks Construction of Trump's 250-Foot Arch Near Arlington Cemetery

U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema's indefinite injunction compounds a legal setback for the planned 'Triumphal Arch,' which now stands blocked by two separate federal courts over concerns it would hinder emergency access near Reagan National Airport and Arlington National Cemetery.

PW
By PressTemps Washington DeskPublished Yesterday, 17:15 ET · 7 min read
Second Federal Judge Blocks Construction of Trump's 250-Foot Arch Near Arlington Cemetery
Memorial Circle, at the Virginia end of Arlington Memorial Bridge (foreground), is the proposed site of President Trump's planned 250-foot arch. Two federal judges have now blocked construction there. (Photo: Duane Lempke/Wikimedia Commons, CC0)
What to know
U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema issued an indefinite injunction on Nov. 20 blocking construction of Trump's planned 250-foot 'Triumphal Arch' at Memorial Circle — the second federal court to halt the project in two weeks
The National Capital Planning Commission approved final site and building plans 8-4 on Nov. 5 after more than a thousand public comments, most opposed; Judge Tanya Chutkan froze construction hours later and has extended her order through Dec. 3
Arlington County's lawsuit argues construction would degrade emergency access near Reagan National Airport and Arlington National Cemetery; the Justice Department says it will appeal Brinkema's ruling 'immediately' to the Fourth Circuit
Neither the project's total cost nor its funding source has been disclosed; the administration has estimated the arch's observation deck could draw between roughly 2,000 and 22,400 visitors a day once built

A second federal judge has blocked construction of President Trump's planned 250-foot "Triumphal Arch" across the Potomac from the Lincoln Memorial, ruling from the bench on Friday that the project poses too great a risk to emergency access near Arlington National Cemetery and Reagan National Airport to proceed while litigation continues. The ruling, reported by PBS NewsHour and other outlets that had reporters in the courtroom, is the second time in two weeks that a federal court has intervened to stop the project, and the first time either has done so without setting an expiration date.

U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema, sitting in the Eastern District of Virginia, issued an indefinite injunction in a suit brought by the Arlington County Board against the National Park Service, two weeks after a separate federal judge in Washington had already put the project on hold. Her order has no expiration date and will remain in effect while the underlying case proceeds, making it the more consequential of the two rulings now standing between the administration and groundbreaking.

Two Courts, One Project, Mounting Numbers

The arch has been moving through a formal federal approval process for more than a year. The National Capital Planning Commission, the federal body that reviews major construction in the capital region, gave the design preliminary approval in July and then voted 8-4 on Nov. 5 to approve final site and building plans, over more than a thousand public comments, most of them opposed, according to CBS News's account of the nearly nine-hour hearing. Commissioners defended the project at length before the vote; NCPC's executive director, Mark Paoletta, who also serves as OMB's general counsel, called it the "grandest arch ever built by mankind" in comments supporting approval.

The numbers behind the design are large by any Washington standard. At 250 feet, the structure would stand roughly twice as tall as the Lincoln Memorial, topped by gilded statuary, and would include a public observation deck the administration has projected could draw between roughly 2,000 and 22,400 visitors a day. It is sited at Memorial Circle, the traffic roundabout at the Virginia end of Arlington Memorial Bridge, construction is expected to take about three years, and neither a total cost nor a funding source has been publicly disclosed; a White House official has said the project is expected to rely on a mix of taxpayer and private money.

Within hours of the Nov. 5 vote, Judge Tanya Chutkan in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia issued a temporary restraining order in a consolidated suit brought by a group of Vietnam War veterans along with the attorneys general of Virginia and the District of Columbia, finding the plaintiffs likely to succeed in showing the government had skipped required legal review. Her written opinion barred construction-related activity for 14 days and required the government to give 48 hours' notice before any site work; she extended the order again on Nov. 18, keeping it in force through Dec. 3 while she weighs a longer-term ruling.

Who the Project Would Touch

The Arlington County Board's suit, filed in October against the National Park Service and the Interior Department, focuses less on the arch's aesthetics than on its physical footprint. County officials argue in their complaint that construction and the traffic it would generate at Memorial Circle would degrade a junction that emergency crews rely on to reach both Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport and Arlington National Cemetery, and that the government's environmental review of those effects was inadequate. Brinkema, in blocking the project, specifically cited the risk to emergency responders who depend on the Arlington Memorial Bridge approach, calling the government's rushed timeline for the project a problem for the court.

Members of the Kennedy family, several of whom are buried at Arlington National Cemetery, filed a separate suit last month citing the arch's effect on the cemetery grounds. Veterans groups have been involved from the start of the fight; the original Chutkan suit was brought in part by Vietnam War veterans who argued the structure would overshadow the cemetery and the bridge's existing war memorials. Preservation groups, including the National Trust for Historic Preservation, have also filed amicus briefs opposing the project on historic-sightline grounds, arguing it would irrevocably alter the view across the bridge between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington National Cemetery that the two sites were designed to share.

"It hurts your credibility with the court."

That line, from Brinkema's bench ruling, was aimed at a Justice Department attorney who argued a decades-old federal statute independently authorized the project regardless of the ongoing environmental and historic-preservation reviews. The judge rejected that argument outright, according to multiple reporters present in the courtroom, and found the county had shown a strong likelihood of succeeding on the merits of its underlying claims.

Reaction on Both Sides

Kate Talmor, an attorney for the nonprofit legal group Democracy Forward representing Arlington County, said after the ruling that the court had recognized "the irreparable harm that will come to people who live and work in Arlington" from what she described as "the massive vanity project." Arlington is home to roughly 230,000 residents and sits directly across the Potomac from the National Mall.

The Justice Department said it would not let the ruling stand unchallenged. A department spokesperson, Matthew Nies, said in a statement that the government "will appeal the district court's decision immediately," signaling the fight will move next to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit. The White House has separately defended the project throughout the review process; spokesperson Davis Ingle said after the Nov. 5 NCPC vote that the administration remained confident it would be "fully vindicated" as litigation plays out, framing the arch as a tribute marking 250 years of American independence.

  • Nov. 5: NCPC approves final site and building plans, 8-4, after nearly nine hours of public comment
  • Nov. 5: Judge Chutkan issues a 14-day temporary restraining order in the D.C. case within hours of the vote
  • Nov. 18: Chutkan extends her order through Dec. 3
  • Nov. 20: Judge Brinkema issues an indefinite injunction in the Arlington County case

Not every official voice has lined up against the project. Some members of Congress who back the administration's broader agenda have defended the arch as a legitimate exercise of executive authority over federal land, even as others, including Rep. Jared Huffman of California, have argued Congress itself should have a vote on a monument of this scale before any construction begins, since no appropriation for the project has been enacted into law. Huffman has gone further than most Democrats, calling the project "illegal" outright on the grounds that the executive branch cannot unilaterally fund and build a monument of this size on federal parkland without specific congressional authorization — an argument that overlaps with, but is legally distinct from, the environmental and traffic-safety claims at the center of both pending lawsuits.

What Happens Next

For now, both rulings leave the project frozen, though on different legal footing. Chutkan's order is explicitly temporary and runs out Dec. 3, after which she is expected to rule on whether to convert it into a longer-term injunction as the underlying case over the government's environmental and historic-preservation review proceeds. Brinkema's order carries no such deadline and will stay in place for as long as the Arlington County case takes to resolve, unless a higher court intervenes first.

That makes the Justice Department's promised appeal to the Fourth Circuit the most immediate thing to watch. If the appeals court agrees to fast-track the government's request, construction could resume well before the underlying lawsuits are resolved on the merits; if it does not, the arch will likely remain stalled through the rest of the current Congress and into next year, by which point the required Section 106 historic-preservation consultation and a fuller environmental review — both still outstanding, according to the county's complaint — would need to be completed regardless of how the court fights turn out. Either way, the administration's timeline for a project it has said should mark the country's 250th anniversary now depends less on the National Capital Planning Commission than on federal judges in two separate courthouses.

More on this story

All Politics