US Edition
Your source for latest news
PoliticsSenate Democrats

Van Hollen presses long-shot bid against Schumer as Senate Democrats near leadership vote

With a secret-ballot vote set for Dec. 1, Sen. Chris Van Hollen is working to peel off votes from Sen. Chuck Schumer in the first contested race for Senate Democratic leader in decades, even as Schumer's camp says he already has enough support to win.

PW
By PressTemps Washington DeskPublished Today, 01:04 ET · 6 min read
Van Hollen presses long-shot bid against Schumer as Senate Democrats near leadership vote
Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.), official Senate portrait. Photo: U.S. Senate Photographic Studio / Frank Fey, Wikimedia Commons, public domain.
What to know
Sen. Chris Van Hollen announced Nov. 12 he will challenge Sen. Chuck Schumer for Senate Democratic leader, a contest multiple outlets describe as the first genuinely open challenge to a sitting Senate Democratic leader in decades; the last comparable near-challenge was in 2004, when Chris Dodd dropped out before facing Harry Reid.
As of Nov. 17, about 15 of 55 incoming Democratic senators had publicly backed Schumer and four had publicly backed Van Hollen; a winner needs roughly 28-29 votes in a secret-ballot vote scheduled for Dec. 1.
Van Hollen has tied his challenge to the Senate's repeated failed votes on Iran war-powers resolutions (one discharge vote failed 47-52) and has floated using the December government funding deadline as leverage to end U.S. involvement.
Schumer has countered with an affordability-focused agenda for the new Congress -- extending ACA subsidies, repealing Canada tariffs, energy permitting legislation and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's removal -- while several senators, including Elissa Slotkin and Jon Ossoff, remain publicly undecided.

Senate Democrats are headed toward a secret-ballot vote on Dec. 1 to decide who leads their caucus in the new Congress, and as of Tuesday neither side in the race between Sen. Chuck Schumer of New York and Sen. Chris Van Hollen of Maryland had publicly locked up the votes needed to win.

Van Hollen announced on Nov. 12 that he would challenge Schumer, who has led Senate Democrats since 2017, in what multiple news organizations have described as the first open challenge to a sitting Senate Democratic leader in decades. The race has played out unusually publicly for a contest that will ultimately be settled behind closed doors.

Where the count stands

Public commitments remain lopsided but incomplete. As of Nov. 17, roughly 15 of the 55 senators who will sit in the Democratic caucus next year had publicly said they would back Schumer, while four had publicly committed to Van Hollen, according to reporting from the Associated Press. Van Hollen has said more than ten senators have privately pledged support, a claim Schumer's allies dispute.

  • Backing Schumer publicly: Sens. Ruben Gallego, Kirsten Gillibrand, Angela Alsobrooks, Catherine Cortez Masto, Tammy Baldwin and Mazie Hirono, among others.
  • Backing Van Hollen publicly: Sen. Bernie Sanders and incoming Sens.-elect Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota.
  • Undecided or noncommittal: Sens. Elissa Slotkin, Tim Kaine, John Hickenlooper, Jon Ossoff and Elizabeth Warren, along with several incoming freshmen still meeting with both camps.

A winner will need a majority of the caucus, a threshold both sides put at roughly 28 or 29 votes depending on the outcome of an Alaska Senate race that had not been finally certified.

A rare contest in Senate history

Contested Senate Democratic leadership races are unusual. The last time a challenge got as far as open vote-counting was in 2004, when Sen. Christopher Dodd of Connecticut weighed a run against Harry Reid after Tom Daschle lost his seat; Dodd dropped out before any formal vote, and Reid was elected without opposition. Senate Democrats have not held a genuinely contested leadership election since, making Van Hollen's challenge, win or lose, notable on its own.

The timing follows the Nov. 3 midterm elections, in which Democrats won majorities in both the House and the Senate. Van Hollen has argued that the sweep is reason to install new leadership rather than return the team that has run the caucus for nearly a decade, telling reporters there should be "no coronation."

The Iran war fight behind the challenge

Much of Van Hollen's case rests on how Senate Democrats have handled the war with Iran. Sen. Tammy Duckworth has repeatedly forced votes on a war-powers resolution, S.J.Res. 123, directing the removal of U.S. forces from hostilities against Iran; an April 15 vote to discharge it from committee failed 47-52, a result recorded in the Senate's own roll call, one of several such losses over the year. Van Hollen was a cosponsor of that effort.

"We gave Republicans a chance to join us in bringing the war to an end, but they refused," Van Hollen said in an April statement from his Senate office after one such vote failed.

Van Hollen has argued Democrats should be willing to use the December government funding deadline as leverage to force an end to U.S. involvement, including, he has suggested, letting funding lapse if necessary. Schumer has not endorsed that approach, and most Democrats have so far been unwilling to tie a shutdown fight to the war.

Schumer's counter-pitch, and the undecided middle

Schumer has largely avoided engaging publicly with Van Hollen's specific criticisms, instead laying out what he and Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand described, at a joint appearance days after the election, as an affordability-focused agenda for the new majority: extending enhanced Affordable Care Act premium tax credits, repealing tariffs including the 50% duties imposed on Canada, and advancing energy permitting legislation while seeking amendments. Gillibrand has separately introduced a companion bill to repeal those tariffs and a measure, the No Stock Act, to bar senior officials from trading individual stocks. Schumer has also called for Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's removal. In an earlier transcript of his own remarks posted by Senate Democrats, Schumer said the caucus would make "health care and other high costs" its top priority. His office has said he is confident the caucus will coalesce behind him once the vote is held.

Several senators who have not committed have given specific reasons for holding off. Slotkin, who has said she will not back Schumer but has not endorsed Van Hollen either, has described a "productive conversation" with him about his candidacy without committing her vote. Hickenlooper has said he is inclined to stick with a leader who helped Democrats flip nine seats. Ossoff has said he wants to hear a fuller policy vision from each candidate before deciding. Incoming freshmen including Annie Andrews of South Carolina and Josh Turek of Iowa have been meeting separately with both men, with Turek saying he wants specifics on rural economic policy, campaign finance and restrictions on stock trading by members of Congress.

Van Hollen has also had to knock down speculation that the campaign is a springboard for a 2028 presidential bid, telling reporters his focus is the leadership post itself. Both camps are expected to spend the next two weeks working the remaining undecided senators before the caucus gathers for its secret-ballot vote on Dec. 1, about a month before the new Congress convenes and Democrats take control of the Senate and House for the first time since 2021.

More on this story

All Politics