US Edition
Your source for latest news
USCourts

Florida carries out record 20th execution of the year after Supreme Court clears final appeal

Thomas Mitchell Overton, 70 — an Army veteran and survivor of Florida's notorious Dozier School for Boys — was put to death by lethal injection Thursday evening for a 1992 double murder, after the U.S. Supreme Court denied his final appeal and stay request earlier in the day, as Florida broke its own death-penalty record for the second year running.

PN
By PressTemps NewsroomPublished Today, 18:19 ET · 6 min read
Florida carries out record 20th execution of the year after Supreme Court clears final appeal
The execution chamber at a Florida prison. (Photo: Florida Department of Corrections / Doug Smith, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain.)
What to know
Florida executed Thomas Mitchell Overton, 70, by lethal injection at 6:19 p.m. Thursday at Florida State Prison in Raiford — the state's 20th execution of 2026, a new modern-era record.
Overton was convicted in 1999 of the 1992 murders of Michael and pregnant Susan "Missy" MacIvor in the Florida Keys; he maintained his innocence to the end, citing forensic irregularities including an untrained chief serologist.
The U.S. Supreme Court denied Overton's final appeal and stay request on November 19, rejecting arguments that Gov. Ron DeSantis's blanket no-clemency stance renders Florida's capital clemency process unconstitutional.
Overton was a U.S. Army veteran and survivor of the Dozier School for Boys, a state reform school where Florida has acknowledged decades of abuse; advocates say at least 11 other Dozier survivors have already been executed.

Florida executed Thomas Mitchell Overton by lethal injection at 6:19 p.m. Thursday at Florida State Prison in Raiford, the Florida Department of Corrections said, making him the 20th person put to death in the state this year and setting a new modern-era record for executions in a single year. The execution went forward after the U.S. Supreme Court denied Overton's final petition for review and declined to issue a stay earlier Thursday, clearing the last legal obstacle to a death warrant Gov. Ron DeSantis had signed four weeks earlier.

Overton, 70, was convicted in 1999 of murdering Michael MacIvor, 30, and his wife, Susan "Missy" MacIvor, 29, who was eight months pregnant, inside their home in Tavernier in the Florida Keys. He had maintained his innocence for more than three decades, and his case drew renewed attention in his final days because of his background: Overton served in the U.S. Army in the 1970s and, as a boy, was sent to the Arthur G. Dozier School for Boys, the state reform school where Florida has since acknowledged decades of physical and sexual abuse of the children in its custody. Strapped to the gurney, Overton used his final statement to repeat his claim of innocence. "I've never sexually assaulted anyone. I never killed anyone. I didn't kill the MacIvors," he said, according to reporters who witnessed the execution.

A three-decade-old case reaches its end

The killings happened in August 1992. According to trial testimony, Overton, who worked at a service station in Tavernier and knew the couple, broke into their home, struck Michael MacIvor and strangled him, then bound, raped and strangled Missy MacIvor. He was not arrested until 1997, after DNA testing in 1996 and 1998 linked him to bedding found at the scene. A jury convicted him in 1999 and recommended death by votes of 9-3 and 8-4 for the two murders — split verdicts that, under the U.S. Supreme Court's 2016 ruling in Hurst v. Florida, would be unconstitutional in a newer case. The Florida Supreme Court later limited that ruling's reach to convictions finalized after June 2002, a cutoff that excluded Overton by a matter of months.

Overton's appeals worked their way through the Florida Supreme Court four separate times over two decades — in 2001, 2007, 2013 and 2018 — each time affirming his conviction and sentence. A fifth round concluded on November 13, when the state's highest court again affirmed the denial of his claims and rejected his request for a stay, days before his execution.

Dozier survivor, veteran, death-row record

Overton became, by advocates' count, at least the 12th execution of a Dozier School survivor, according to tracking by the Death Penalty Information Center, a research group critical of capital punishment. Florida's legislature formally apologized to Dozier survivors in 2017, and DeSantis signed a compensation law for some of them in 2024. Overton also became, by the same tally, the 15th military veteran executed under DeSantis's tenure and one of 119 veterans Florida has sentenced to death — more than any other state.

DeSantis has signed death warrants at a pace unmatched by any Florida governor in the modern death-penalty era, which began when the U.S. Supreme Court reinstated capital punishment in 1976. Overton's execution was the governor's 20th warrant carried out this year alone, breaking the state's own record of 19 executions set in 2025. DeSantis has said publicly, in 2021, that he would not grant clemency to anyone convicted of murder — a position that has drawn its own legal challenge. No Florida death-row inmate has received clemency in more than four decades.

A late appeal over forensics and clemency

In the days before the execution, Overton's attorneys pressed two separate arguments. One, raised in state court, revisited long-standing doubts about the forensic work in his case: the county's chief serologist at the time was a veterinarian without formal training in forensic science who, according to case materials compiled by Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, stored evidence at his own home and at one point let a psychic consulted by the sheriff's office handle it. Overton's lawyers also said hair found on tape used to bind Missy MacIvor did not visually match him and was never subjected to DNA testing, and that a jailhouse informant who testified against him later said investigators had coached him.

The second argument went to the U.S. Supreme Court directly. In a petition filed November 14, Overton's counsel argued that Florida's clemency system has become "a sham" because the governor has categorically ruled out mercy for anyone convicted of murder, while state law bars a death warrant from being signed until the clemency process has run its course. The petition, filed alongside a request to stay the execution, asked the justices to decide whether that combination violates due process. The appendix filed with the petition included the lower courts' orders rejecting that same argument. The state filed its opposition November 17, and on November 19 — the day of the execution — the justices denied both the stay application and the petition itself without noted dissent, according to the court's public docket.

Advocacy groups that had long opposed Overton's execution framed it, in the final days, around his childhood at Dozier rather than his claims of innocence alone.

"Florida failed Jesse Guardado and Thomas Overton when they were children in its custody. The harm they later caused does not erase what the state did to them. Florida's acknowledgment of the abuse at Dozier must extend to mercy for the men who survived it."

That statement came from Grace Hanna, executive director of Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty, in a post urging DeSantis to halt the execution before it went forward. Guardado, a fellow Dozier survivor and Vietnam-era veteran, was executed earlier this month in Florida's 19th execution of the year.

What's next

Florida's execution pace shows no sign of slowing. DeSantis has continued signing warrants even as the state approached this record, including one earlier this month for a man convicted in the 1998 killing of a 7-year-old girl, suggesting 2026's total will likely be extended further before year's end. Nationally, Florida alone has accounted for a large share of all executions carried out in the United States this year, reinforcing a trend criminal-justice researchers have tracked for several years: as other states slow or pause executions, Florida and a handful of others have accelerated them.

For death-penalty opponents, Overton's case is likely to remain a reference point in the broader fight over how Florida treats survivors of its own reform-school system who went on, as adults, to commit crimes that led to death sentences. For the family of Michael and Missy MacIvor, Thursday's execution closed a case that outlasted a trial, five rounds of state appeals and two separate petitions to the nation's highest court, spanning more than 34 years since the murders occurred.

More on this story

All US