US Edition
Your source for latest news
OpinionIsrael's coalition standoff

Opinion: Netanyahu's push for a "unity government" is a bid to undo an election he lost

A parliamentary vote on the Knesset speakership, set for Tuesday, is the first real test of whether Benjamin Netanyahu's call for "national unity" is sincere — or a stalling tactic aimed at reversing a result his own bloc did not win.

PW
By PressTemps World DeskPublished Today, 12:50 ET · 6 min read
Opinion: Netanyahu's push for a "unity government" is a bid to undo an election he lost
The Knesset building in Jerusalem, photographed from the Israel Museum. Lawmakers there are at the center of the coalition standoff that has followed Israel's October 2026 election. Photo: Beny Shlevich / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
What to know
Israel's October 27 election left Netanyahu's bloc with 53 of 120 Knesset seats, eight short of a majority, while Gadi Eisenkot's bloc and Arab-led parties together hold 67 seats.
President Herzog gave Eisenkot the mandate to form a government on November 8, with a deadline of roughly December 6 that can be extended to December 20.
Netanyahu has renewed calls for a "national unity government," citing the Iranian threat, while still facing a corruption trial his own defense team says could stretch into 2028.
A Knesset vote scheduled for November 17 to replace Speaker Amir Ohana is being treated by both sides as the first real test of whether Netanyahu's party will accept the election result or keep obstructing it.

Three weeks after Israeli voters denied Benjamin Netanyahu a majority, the caretaker prime minister is trying to win back through persuasion what he lost at the ballot box. He is calling it a "national unity government." It is better understood as an attempt to erase the result of an election.

On Tuesday, the newly seated Knesset is scheduled to vote on replacing Speaker Amir Ohana, a Netanyahu loyalist, with Matan Kahana of the Yashar party. It sounds like parliamentary housekeeping. It is not. The vote is the first hard test of whether Netanyahu's bloc will accept the arithmetic of the October 27 election or keep looking for ways around it.

What the voters actually decided

The numbers are not in serious dispute. After a count that drew 5.7 million ballots and the highest turnout since 1999, Israel's Central Elections Committee certified that Netanyahu's right-wing and ultra-Orthodox bloc won 53 of the Knesset's 120 seats — eight short of a majority — while Gadi Eisenkot's four-party opposition bloc took 48 and Arab-led parties took a combined 19. Committee chairman Justice Noam Sohlberg rejected claims of fraud pressed by Netanyahu's camp and warned that casting doubt on the count without evidence posed "a real danger" to Israeli democracy.

Put plainly: 67 of 120 lawmakers do not want Netanyahu as prime minister. That is why President Isaac Herzog, after formal consultations in which those 67 members recommended Eisenkot against 46 for Netanyahu, handed the former chief of staff the mandate to form a government on November 8. Under Israel's Basic Law: The Government, Eisenkot has 28 days from that date — until roughly December 6 — with a possible 14-day extension, to assemble 61 votes in the chamber.

A security pitch that doubles as a political lifeline

Netanyahu has not conceded the point. After meeting Eisenkot on November 12, he released a video statement two days later renewing his appeal for a unity government, arguing it was the only way to "eliminate the Iranian threat once and for all" and warning that Tehran would "not hesitate to use nuclear weapons against us." He asked Eisenkot to "meet in one room, without preconditions," and said a narrow, Arab-backed minority government would lead to Israel's "collapse."

The appeal lands against a genuinely tense backdrop. The Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps has twice this month claimed to have struck a U.S. early-warning radar installation in Bahrain, and Bahrain's military says it intercepted drones aimed at the base — a reminder that the ceasefire ending the February war between Israel, the United States and Iran remains fragile. That is a real security concern. But it is also, conveniently, the argument of a politician who stands to lose power, and who is still on trial for bribery, fraud and breach of trust — a case his own defense team says could stretch into 2028. Eisenkot was not persuaded that the two were unconnected.

"He knows he lost the election," Eisenkot said of Netanyahu, dismissing the unity overture as a tactic rather than a principle. "These tricks don't work on me."

Eisenkot, a retired lieutenant general who commanded the Israel Defense Forces from 2015 to 2019 and quit Netanyahu's wartime emergency government in June 2024 in protest over its conduct of the Gaza war, has said Likud members are welcome to join a government — under his premiership, with no rotation. That is the sticking point Netanyahu's camp will not accept, which is what makes his "no preconditions" framing somewhat misleading: the precondition he will not state out loud is that he remains prime minister.

Who actually has the votes, and why it is awkward

Eisenkot's bloc plus the Arab-led Joint List and Ra'am add up to 67 seats, comfortably more than the 61 needed to govern. In a system that worked purely on arithmetic, that would settle the matter. It has not, because a working taboo in mainstream Israeli politics treats reliance on Arab parties' votes as illegitimate even when those votes come from citizens who voted lawfully for parties competing openly for Knesset seats. Avigdor Liberman and Naftali Bennett, both potential partners of Eisenkot, have ruled out governing with Arab-party support, even in the passive form of abstention on a confidence vote. That has pushed Eisenkot toward courting the ultra-Orthodox parties Shas and United Torah Judaism instead — a coalition that would reach 61 seats but requires resolving the single issue that has destabilized Israeli coalitions for years: whether yeshiva students are exempted from military conscription that secular and religious-Zionist Israelis perform. Eisenkot and Liberman have so far refused the written commitment the Haredi parties are demanding.

The people with the most at stake in this stalemate are not the party leaders bargaining over portfolios. They are the roughly one million Arab citizens of Israel whose votes are treated as disqualifying rather than decisive; the families of reservists who have borne a disproportionate share of three years of war while a political settlement on burden-sharing is repeatedly deferred; and a public that delivered a clear verdict on October 27 and has watched it be relitigated in meeting rooms ever since.

What the speaker vote will actually test

Tuesday's vote has legal teeth because of a precedent Netanyahu's own camp cannot easily dismiss. In 2020, Israel's Supreme Court ruled, in a case brought by the Movement for Quality Government in Israel, that a Knesset speaker cannot block a vote on his own replacement once 61 members demand one — language the court tied explicitly to "the essence of the democratic process," which it defined as the ability to translate votes into governance. That ruling, in Movement for Quality Government in Israel v. Speaker of the Knesset, forced Yuli Edelstein to resign rather than comply when he tried to stall a vote in similarly deadlocked circumstances. The Knesset's own Rules of Procedure likewise require a new speaker to be elected once the post is vacated, through the same open-ballot process as the original election. Sixty-seven members signed the request for Tuesday's vote. If Ohana's allies try to delay or frustrate it, the 2020 precedent says plainly that they cannot.

Eisenkot's bloc has framed the vote as exactly that kind of test, as Al Jazeera's reporting on the standoff has laid out in detail: if Likud cooperates in replacing its own speaker with a nominee from the bloc that actually commands the Knesset's confidence, that is a sign Netanyahu's unity talk might be sincere. If Likud fights it, the unity offer is confirmed as a stalling tactic aimed at running down Eisenkot's clock, which expires in early December and cannot be renewed a second time without a fresh and far less favorable process.

What should happen now

Israel does not owe Netanyahu a second chance to form the government that voters took away from him. It owes its citizens a government that reflects the Knesset actually elected on October 27. If Eisenkot can assemble 61 votes, whether through the Haredi parties or through an honestly acknowledged reliance on Arab-party abstention, he should be allowed to do so without his own Knesset's presiding officer working to deny him procedural footing. Likud is entitled to oppose that government in opposition. It is not entitled to use control of the speaker's gavel to prevent the chamber from functioning while its leader looks for a backdoor into a job the electorate did not give him. Tuesday's vote will show which path Netanyahu's party has chosen.

More on this story

All Opinion