US Edition
Your source for latest news
ScienceAstrophysics

Largest star survey yet pins the Milky Way's mass at 1.19 trillion suns

The DESI collaboration tested four separate methods of weighing the galaxy against thousands of simulated Milky Ways before trusting the result on real data, producing the most rigorously validated mass estimate yet for the galaxy we live in.

PS
By PressTemps Science DeskPublished Today, 13:12 ET · 6 min read
Largest star survey yet pins the Milky Way's mass at 1.19 trillion suns
The Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument, mounted on the Nicholas U. Mayall 4-meter Telescope at Kitt Peak National Observatory in Arizona, surveyed more than 10,000 stars in the Milky Way's outer halo for the new mass measurement. Photo: NOIRLab/KPNO/NSF/AURA/P. Marenfeld, CC BY 4.0
What to know
DESI measured the Milky Way's total mass at 1.19 trillion solar masses, with an uncertainty of about 11 percent, using more than 10,000 distant halo stars from its second data release.
Four independent modeling methods were each tested on simulated mock galaxies before being applied to real data, specifically to separate genuine findings from hidden methodological bias.
The new figure is broadly consistent with earlier, separate estimates based on the orbits of the Milky Way's satellite galaxies, suggesting past disagreements in the field came from unverified assumptions rather than real ambiguity.
The DESI team is releasing its data, mock catalogs and code publicly so other astronomers can test the result independently, with a larger follow-up project already planned.

An international team of astronomers has produced the most rigorously tested measurement yet of the Milky Way's total mass, putting it at roughly 1.19 trillion times the mass of the sun, with an uncertainty of about 11 percent. The result comes from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) collaboration, which used more than 10,000 stars in the galaxy's distant halo to weigh the Milky Way, including both its visible matter and its unseen dark matter.

The study, posted this month as a DESI DR2 results paper, is less notable for the number itself than for how it was obtained. Rather than publishing a single estimate, the collaboration ran four independent methods of measuring galactic mass on the same stellar data, then checked every method against thousands of simulated "mock" galaxies before trusting it on the real sky. That cross-checking, described in a companion paper on the DESI project's own research blog, was designed specifically to answer a question that has dogged Milky Way mass studies for decades: how much of the disagreement between past measurements comes from the universe, and how much comes from the assumptions built into the models.

A number that has resisted pinning down

Astronomers have tried to weigh the Milky Way for the better part of a century, and the estimates have never converged tightly. A 2023 review of the literature found that across 20 published estimates of the galaxy's so-called virial mass, the values differed enough to produce a spread of roughly a quarter of a trillion solar masses around an average of about 0.88 trillion suns, while estimates of a related quantity clustered around 1.02 trillion suns with an even wider scatter, according to the review by Vadim Bobylev and Anisa Bajkova. Other approaches have pulled in different directions entirely: some studies modeling the rotation of the galaxy's visible disk have suggested a mass closer to a fifth of a trillion suns, far below estimates built from the motion of distant halo stars and satellite galaxies.

Much of that scatter reflects the difficulty of the underlying problem. More than 95 percent of the Milky Way's mass is invisible dark matter, so its presence can only be inferred indirectly, by measuring how fast stars and star clusters move under its gravitational pull at various distances from the galactic center. Different tracers, different distances and different statistical assumptions have tended to produce different answers, and it has been hard to tell whether a given measurement failed because of real complexity in the galaxy or because of a flaw in the method.

Thousands of stars, four separate methods

The new analysis draws on DESI's second major data release, a survey of millions of stars and galaxies conducted with a robotically controlled instrument, fitted with 5,000 fiber-optic positioners, on the Nicholas U. Mayall 4-meter Telescope at Kitt Peak National Observatory in Arizona. From that survey, the team selected 10,036 RR Lyrae and blue horizontal-branch stars — two well-understood types of old, pulsing or evolved stars that double as reliable distance markers — scattered through the galaxy's outer halo, between roughly 30,000 and 310,000 light-years from the galactic center.

Four separate research groups then applied four different dynamical modeling techniques to that same stellar sample, each testing its approach first on six simulated Milky Way-like galaxies viewed from four different vantage points, to see how far off each method's answer could be pushed by its own hidden assumptions. One method, the group found, overestimated enclosed mass by about 15 percent when run on the mock galaxies, a bias the team corrected for before combining results. The two stellar populations also disagreed with each other by about 20 percent at a radius of 260,000 light-years when analyzed with the same method, a reminder that systematic effects, not just measurement noise, dominate the uncertainty in this kind of study.

After folding in those corrections, the combined analysis put the mass enclosed within 260,000 light-years of the galactic center at about 640 billion solar masses, with an uncertainty of roughly 8 percent, and extrapolated the galaxy's total virial mass — the mass out to the radius where it is considered gravitationally bound — at 1.19 trillion solar masses. The team also found that the result depends somewhat on which direction a hypothetical observer looks from within the simulated galaxies, a sign that the Milky Way, which is still accreting smaller satellite galaxies and is not in a settled dynamical state, may be lumpier or less spherical than the simplest models assume.

Alex Riley, an astrophysicist at Durham University and a co-author of the mock-catalog study underpinning the analysis, said the headline figure "is not the smallest uncertainty in the literature or a particularly shocking value," adding that what stood out to him was "all the tests we did, and how open we are about the results of those tests."

Why the figure matters

The Milky Way's total mass is a basic input for a wide range of other astronomical work. It shapes models of how the galaxy formed and how it will interact with its largest neighbor, the Andromeda galaxy, over the next several billion years. It sets the gravitational backdrop against which astronomers interpret the orbits of small satellite galaxies and globular clusters, and it provides one of the closest, most detailed test cases available for theories of how dark matter is distributed within galaxies generally, since the Milky Way is the one galaxy whose structure can be mapped star by star rather than inferred from its light alone.

A separate DESI paper examining the same question with a second method, led by astronomer Jiaxin Han, found that the new halo-star-based estimate lines up well with constraints previously derived from the motion of the Milky Way's satellite galaxies, a result the team took as evidence that earlier, more scattered estimates in the literature were often driven by unjustified assumptions and overlooked sources of systematic error, rather than by any real ambiguity in the galaxy's mass. If that interpretation holds up, it would mean the decades-long disagreement over the Milky Way's weight was less a sign of deep uncertainty about dark matter and more a problem of insufficiently tested methodology — a distinction that matters for how much confidence astronomers can place in mass estimates of other, more distant galaxies that cannot be studied in anywhere near this level of detail.

What comes next

The DESI team says it is now making the underlying data, mock catalogs and analysis code publicly available, specifically so that other research groups can apply their own modeling techniques to the same stellar sample and test the result independently, as reported by Phys.org. That kind of open replication was central to the project's design from the outset: the comparison of methods was the point, not a single new number.

Looking ahead, the collaboration plans a follow-up project that would roughly double the number of independent modeling methods under comparison, extend the stellar sample to greater distances, and bring in an entirely different class of tracer — long, thin streams of stars torn from disrupted satellite galaxies and star clusters, which retain a memory of the Milky Way's gravitational field even though the galaxy is not in a settled, symmetric state. That approach builds on the collaboration's earlier first-data-release measurement of the galaxy's outer halo mass, published last year, and is expected to further narrow the uncertainty that has surrounded one of astronomy's most basic numbers: how much the galaxy we live in actually weighs.

More on this story

All Science